p.1
ಹ੮১য মੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভ
ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ਃચ૩भ൧पउऐॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभু ਬ
ൿقൿದكૣ
ি ર ௗಛয়ऋ॒ ७থॱش ি ፶ ਣপ৾ িরೢ ਮ ઋૺ প৾ ཪ੶ ದଠൡপ৾ ௳ম ଠ৶े ौतৼਚ୰ প ূ ୢ ఐপ৾ ౣ
ૐ
ಹ੮১যমੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভੱ
ग़॥شफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থਛ৩ভ
ਗ௬
ি⁕ ਣஉপ৾ நఈ ൞ূ ঋॖ ؞ఓਆୢ ७থॱش
ਗਪഭ
ಹ੮১যমᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ ভ
फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থਛ৩ভ
p.2
৯ઃ
ਸ਼, ฆ ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ਃ૩؟ قڭك ၖभూବ 3 قڮك ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ਃચ૩पउऐॊ৷ୁ भଝ 3 قگك &75&' भ൧੦धඪ২ীథ 3 قڰك &75&' भᄄ২؞धଫ൧भਔଝ 3 قڱك &75&' भজ५ॡಽશ৲धঐॿش४ওথॺ 3 ਸ਼,, ฆ &75&' भ൧ قڭك ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ 3
L ంઽೠચ 3 LL ంఁચ 3 LLL కਃચधཡဿಓ 3 قڮك जभभॖ ওش४থॢ 3
L ටறୢ৾ قੱ ൙३থॳॢ ছইॕ شك 3 LL ට05, 3 ਸ਼,,, ฆ ऋ॒ ఇ১॑ ষअ೩पৌघॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभউটॺ॥شঝ قڭك ऋ॒ ఇ১भੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ 3 قڮك ऋ॒ ఇ১রभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ 3
L ইज़টش॔ ॵউभᄄ২ध 3 LL ਫ਼ਪඨ৯ 3 قگكऋ॒ ఇ১ીവभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ
L ইज़টش॔ ॵউभᄄ২ध 3 LL ਫ਼ਪඨ৯ 3 ਸ਼,9 ฆ ඊႵॳख़ॵॡএॖ থॺ༛૩ఇपे ॊੱ ഷଵ૩ قڭك 3 قڮك ,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भੱ ग़॥شਚৄ 3 قگك ,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भ൧੦ 3 قڰك ग़॥شਫ਼ਪधঔॲজॸॕ धभଁ় ௬ 3 قڱك ,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भ 3 ਸ਼9 ฆ ऋ॒ पൣ अजभभ় ಡඪੱ ग़॥شपे ॊ௬धৌૢ قڭك ཡৈഷಓඪ 3 قڮك ञऒणऻඪණ 3
p.3
ਸ਼9, ฆ ଣೝभੱ ഷଵႈ೩
قڭك 3 قڮك 3
L Ⴭႈ೩ 3 LL ൙૩ 3 LLL ఉჍඪ 3 LY ་ဿႈ೩ 3 قگك ଣೝभইज़টش॔ ॵউ 3 ਸ਼9,, ฆੱ ग़॥شੑ पउऐॊৰಏ෫भି ਔਡ قڭك ᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ भਤனधੱ ग़॥شभ૽ સ 3 قڮك &75&' भঔॽॱজথॢ ఏधಖ২ଵ৶भਏਙ 3 قگك ग़॥شಖ২ଵ৶भञीभதఠణਫ਼ਪपउऐॊ৳ஹधઇ 3 قڰك ग़॥شਫ਼ਪपउऐॊਔਡ 3
L ੑ க؞ঋش५ছॖ থੑ கभનੳ 3 LL गਫ਼पे ॊੑ 3 LLL गਃஓपे ॊੑ 3 LY கभ༜ਊਙपणःथभનੳ 3 قڱك যੵ ੴચقDUWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFH$,كभણ৷ 3 قڲك گ'ੱ ग़॥شभણ৷ 3 قڳك ग़॥شઈிભ 3
અધ൴ 3
p.4
ਸ਼⋛ฆ ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ൙૩؟
قڭكၖभూବ
মੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভदम ফपَಿ ऋ॒ දঢ়৴ੱ ൙૩भ൧पउऐॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼
ਪभু ਬُ॑ ਛखञق ফਸ਼ ග ਰৣَু ਬُ ك؛जभؚ ফप(6&ق(XURSHDQ6RFLHW\ RI&DUGLRORJ\ ପੱ ට୰৾ ভكऋ(+$ق(XURSHDQ+HPDWRORJ\$VVRFLDWLRQ ପഷั৾ ভكؚ(6752 ق(XURSHDQ 6RFLHW\ IRU 7KHUDSHXWLF 5DGLRORJ\ DQG 2QFRORJ\ ପଣೝᇯᯂ৾ ভكؚ ,&26 ق,QWHUQDWLRQDO&DUGLR2QFRORJ\6RFLHW\ বᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ ভكध় द ফपমᇯᯂ୭ ஓ৾ ভधমಏ෫ᇯᯂ৾ ভऋ় द ᇯᯂ୭ஓफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ॑ खञ؛औै पؚ ,&,ق,PPXQH FKHFNSRLQWLQKLELWRU ඊႵॳख़ॵॡএॖ থॺ༛૩දكऩनभৗखःऋ॒ ఇ১॑ அिঞ४ওথऋఃৃ खؚੱ ൙༇ऩनभৗञऩ୰ଙ॑ ৽ୡघॊਃভऋੜखथःॊ؛ऒभे अऩ૾ யৣ पउःथੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ ਪमॎै ङؚੱ ൙૩भਫ਼লपउःथ।شॺय़شঃشभ૽ સ॑ ટञघశଞपਏऩॶشঝदँ ॉؚ ऒ भञलু ਬ॑ ၖघॊऒधधऩढञ؛ऩउমഺभ2QFRFDUGLRORJ\ फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থपउऐॊ&75&' قFDQFHUWKHUDS\UHODWHGFDUGLDFG\VIXQFWLRQك੶पगथ ਬभَ॑ ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ਃચ ૩भ൧पउऐॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभু ਬُ धಌखञ؛ قڮكऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ਃચ૩पउऐॊ৷ୁ भଝ &75&' मؚੱ ग़॥ش୩ୠदम॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇදؚಿ +(5ಿ ৬ఇपे ॊਛযभఇදਙੱ ൙ ૩قऋؚ॒ பਙজথঃᇯؚ भஜഷ୰ؚ ᇯऩनभఇ১॑ ਭऐञ೩ك॑ৌधखथ*/6ق*OREDO ORQJLWXGLQDO VWUDLQكपे ॊ&75&' ଫ൧भग़অॹথ५ऋનয়औोञ৽༬ऩनऊैؚ FDQFHU WKHUDSHXWLFVUHODWHGFDUGLDFG\VIXQFWLRQقಿ ऋ॒ දঢ়৴ੱ ൙૩كऩनभ৷ୁ ऋ৷ःै ोथऌञ ഄఴ৽༬ऋँ ॊ؛্ؚ ಏ෫ਠৃ दमఇදਰਗभपൣ अੱ ഷଵ૩ऽदஅीथभୁ ऋ৷ःै ोॊऒधऋँ ॊऋؚ মু ਬदम৷ୁ भ॑ ೂऐॊञीؚ ଣೝपକघॊੱ ഷଵ૩म5,+' ق5DGLDWLRQLQGXFHG KHDUW GLVHDVHكधखؚ ඊႵॳख़ॵॡএॖ থॺ༛૩ఇقLPPXQH FKHFNSRLQW LQKLELWRUV؟,&,Vكपൣ अੱ ൙༇मؚ ඊႵঢ়৴થ૩হقLU$(LPPXQHUHODWHGDGYHUVHHYHQWكभ णधखथেगॊ,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇धखथॉඞअ؛ऒोै म&75&' धम౮ऩॊ୰ଙदँ ॉঐॿش४ওথ ॺृ ্ ଉु ౮ऩॊञीયશघसऌदँ ॊ؛ञटखৰपम&75&' भਉఇද॑ ਫનपયશघॊऒ धऋऩඪु ৽ୡऔोॊ؛ڭ प(6& ᇯᯂ୭ஓफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থऩनप੦तऌؚ &75&'ؚ ,&, पे ॊੱ ൙༇पਸइथഷଵႈ೩قಯဿഷዟؚ ဿഷዟऩनكؚ ৈഷಓඪؚਂ ତဿ॑ ಡघॊऋ॒ ॑ં घ؛ قگك&75&' भ൧੦धඪ২ীథ
(6& फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থमؚ &75&' भඪ২ীథ॑ ৗञपखञقك؛ऒभඪ২मؚ ऋ॒
भಲਢ؞ಌृؚ &75&' قలਟपੱ ৳૧ఇ॑ রૃ दऌॊऊಉكभਔઓৠपઉघॊञीؚ &75&' भ൧धৎपඪ২॑ ન৲घॊऒधभਏਙऋਘ৹औोथःॊ؛धऎप૮ඪਙ&75&' भ ඪ২ਖ਼मؚ ంฌল૨ق/9()كध*/6॑ ৷ःॊञीؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪऋরੱ धऩॊ؛ऩउؚ ऋ॒ ୩ ୠभથ૩হ௬पम&7&$(ق&RPPRQ7HUPLQRORJ\&ULWHULDIRU$GYHUVH(YHQWVكऋ৷ःै ोॊ؛ &7&$( द௬घॊَ થ૩হُ धम೩औ॒ ऋਭऐॊँैॅ ॊऽखऎऩःඉदँ ॉؚ ङखु
p.5
૪઼ धभટঢ়બऋऩःਡदَౢ ৷ُ धम౮ऩॊৃ় ऋँ ॊ؛ඪ২म*UDGH दऔोؚ *UDGLQJ
मਰৣ भधउॉदँ ॊ؛*UDGH मೄ২ऩથ૩হق૮ඪ૾ ऽञमೄऩඪ૾ؚ ೄऩਫ਼ਪਚৄ كद ஂ োਂ ਏऩु भदँ ॉऋ॒ मಲਢ૭ચदँ ॊऒधऋः؛*UDGH मরಉ২भથ૩হقඪ૾ मँ
ॊऋফೡৼૢ भମभॉਰਗभଞেણभपधनऽॊكदँ ॉਈ৵طଂਚطశ ॑ ਏघॊ؛ऋ॒ मభऽञमরऔोॊৃ় ऋँ ॊ؛*UDGH मඪऽञमୢ৾ पপदँ ॊ ऋؚ ञटठपে୵॑ ะऊघु भदमऩःથ૩হदँ ॉোऽञमোभభশ॑ ਏघॊ؛ຄষরभ ऋ॒ मরعીവقঞ४ওথभಌ॑ அिكऔोॊ؛*UDGH मে୵॑ ะऊघથ૩হदಸ૪઼॑
ਏघॊ؛ऋ॒ मીവऔोॊ؛*UDGH मથ૩হपे ॊଈಝदँ ॊ؛ऩउؚ &7&$(9HU दमੱ ට૩ؚ ంਃચਂ ৸भඨऋླྀ ৗऔोਰৣ भे अपਝऔोञ؛*UDGH؟ంฌল૨ق/9()كۺ ऊणਰৣ भ णਰ॑ ञघ؛ك*/6 भঋش५ছॖ থऊै भ॑ தइॊৗञऩৣؚ كੱ ටংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شभৗञऩಊ؛*UDGH؟/9() ऋऊणਰৣ भ णਰ॑ ञघ؛ك/9() भ ਰभৣؚ ك*/6 भঋش५ছॖ থऊै भ॑ தइॊৗञऩৣؚ كੱ ටংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شभৗञऩ ಊ؛*UDGH؟ৗञप/9() ऋपৣ ؛*UDGH भਝमऩः؛ قڰك&75&' भᄄ২؞धଫ൧भਔଝ
থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথधॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈ॑ ৎଖखञঞ४ওথقع ফكदमంਃ
ચ૩ऋ٫ؚੱਂ ৸ऋ٫धாഈपऎ ऒभঞ४ওথ॑ ೂऐॊऒधऋတऔोथःॊ؛ ফ ع ফपষॎोञ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇදपৌघॊੱ ৳૧ఇभટ॑ ௬घॊञीभছথॲ৲ૻ
ຎୡق5&7ك॑ ૐ৺खञওॱ॔ ॼজ३५पे ॊधؚ /9() मঋش५ছॖ থऊै নাभৎਡद قكৣ खؚ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇදଖमॻय़९ঝঅ३থఌदPJP दँ ढञ؛ऩउऒभওॱ॔ ॼজ३५मऋ॒ ඪभऺ ऊपഷั ऋ॒ ඪ॑ ৌधखञଢ଼ु அऽोथःॊ؛ ফ৻प॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇදऋઞ৷औोमगी ফ৻पੱ ਙभਾઔऋৼઃःटञी ফभঞ४ওথमੱ ਙपଦൟऔोथउॉؚ ऒभऒधऋખऔोथःॊधઅइॊ؛॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ ఇදपे ॊ&75&' मຄڭফਰप٫भඪऋඪघॊधॎोथःॊ؛औै पؚ &75&' ඪ ඪपउःथଫपੱਂ ৸ஂ োघोयपખૢ घॊન૨ऋੜइॊऒधऋં औोथःॊ؛ऒभञीؚ &75&' भଫ൧؞ஂ োऋਏदँ ॊ؛ قڱك&75&' भজ५ॡಽશ৲धঐॿش४ওথॺ
(6& फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থदम&75&' भজ५ॡ௬১॑ खथःॊ؛ੱਙସषभച່ٙੱਂ ৸জ५ॡقੱਂ ৸५ॸش४$كदँ ॊभद ঞ४ওথओधपੱ ग़॥شইज़টشभᄄ২ऋတऔोथः ॊ؛&75&' मَ କऒढथऊै ৌ૪घॊभदमःُ धऔोथउॉؚ ऋ॒ ৫ৎق৫كभঋش५ ছॖ থ௬ؚ ऋ॒ রभঐॿش४ওথॺق१شঋॖ ছথ५كؚ ऋ॒ ຄभ१ংॖ ংش३ॵউॣ॔ ऋਏदँ ॊ؛ङखु ৸दঐॿش४ওথॺऋਏदमऩःऋؚੱ ਙभँ ॊऋ॒ ॑ ষऔोॊ জ५ॡभৈःඪपৌखथரੈ ௮द় ৶ऩஂ ো্ ১॑ ਝभ૾ யप় ॎचथਫ਼ୈघॊऒधऋ ीै ोॊ؛
p.6
ਸ਼,, ฆ &75&' भ൧
قڭكੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ
ग़॥شਫ਼ਪमؚ ଣೝयऎऋऩऎశदؚ ॉନखষदऌؚ ಹಏ෫दઁ ऎख
थःॊ؛ম১पे ॉؚ &75&' भ൧੦दਹ৷औोॊ/9() ऋੑ दऌॊ؛खञऋढथؚੱ ਙभ૭ચ ਙऋँ ॊఇදृ ଣೝ১पे ॊऋ॒ भੱ ਃચ௬ؚ ऋ॒ রعपउऐॊੱ ਃચঔॽॱ জথॢ पउःथؚ ਈु ᄄ৷औोथःॊ൸ਫ਼ਪ১दँ ॊ؛ऽञম১मؚ ంउे लకभ१ॖ ६ؚੱ
ਃચقઽೠચؚ ఁચكभ௬॑ घॊञीप৷ःै ोॊटऐदऩऎؚ༘ ഷਙੱ ႈ೩ؚ ఉჍඪؚ পഷଵႈ ೩ؚ ཡৈഷಓඪੱ Ⴭႈ೩ऩनஓସऩੱ ؞ഷଵႈ೩ؚੱ ටᇯᯂقਉਙؚ ૡਙكभ൧ृ ୰ଙभඪ ২௬पु ᄄ৷औोॊ؛णऽॉؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪमؚ &75&' भ൧भाऩै ङؚ ᇯᯂ୭ஓ൧पउ ऐॊੱ ႈ೩भ൧पઁ ऎથ৷दँ ॊ؛ Lంઽೠચ D/9()
&75&' पउऐॊੱ ਃચ૩भଝपஅऽोथउॉؚ ਫનऊणગਠਙऋ૿ ৳औोञ௬ऋ
ीै ोॊ؛ ⋇ੑ ্ ১
ಽ১पे ॊੱ ᒷએउे लੱ ᒷએ॑ ৷ःथؚ ઽೠଜउे लఁଜभంੱ Ⴭੀ॑ ॺঞش५खथলघॊॹॕ ५ॡ১ऋတऔोॊ؛ञटखؚ ॹॕ ५ॡ১पे ॊ/9() भपु ਖਡऋँ ॉؚ ङखु ગਠਙऋৈःधमइऩः؛ऒोै पৌघॊৰಏ෫पउऐॊৌૢ पणःथम घॊقਸ਼⋝ฆك؛৪বੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভق$6(كପੱ ഷଵ൸৾ ভق($&9,كम ઃ੪ੱ ग़॥ش১ पे ॊ/9() भ॑ တखथःॊ؛தఠణ൧ಎ઼ धঽੑ ૼ भਤనपे ॉؚ ంઍपঢ়ख थमؚ ઃ੪ੱ ग़॥ش১पे ॉଐऩ൸ॹشॱऋ੭दऌोयؚ ॹॕ ५ॡ১दीञகे ॉु ਫનद ગਠਙभৈःੑ கऋ੭ै ोॊे अपऩढञ؛खऊखؚ ঝشॳথदگઃ੪ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ষखथः ॊਝमऩऎؚ ସभਖऊैੑ ऋ૭ચऩऋै ोॊऒधؚ ઃ੪ੱ ग़॥ش১पे ॊ/9() भ ਫଞகमॹॕ ५ॡ১धम౮ऩॉ &75&' पउऐॊढ़ॵॺड़ইகऋৠऽढथःऩःऒधऩनऊैؚ ਠৎ ਡदम&75&' पउऐॊৢ ଞ൧पउःथमတदऌऩः؛ৢ ଞभ&75&' मलऽ॒ ਙभంઈ౮ ଞ॑ Ⴋघॊऋؚ ऋ॒ ఇ১म༘ ഷਙੱ ႈ೩भඪজ५ॡ॑ ੜপऔचॊञी ంଂਚઈ౮ଞ॑ ऌञघৃ় ऋँ ॊ؛ంઈमङखु पৣ घॊॎऐदमऩःऒधؚ /9() भਫનऩ௬ऋ ीै ोॊऒधऩनऊैؚ ଳಁ ௬H\HEDOO ()ृ 0 ঔشॻ১पे ॊ7HLFKKRO] ১पे ॊ௬दमਂે
ীधઅइै ोॊ؛ ⋈੦க
ফपষऔोञ$6(ੱ ᒷफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থदमؚ /9() भਫଞৣ கम٫दँ ढञ؛
जभञीؚ &75&' भ൧੦भ/9()ु ٫ऋ৷ःै ोथःञ؝ ফपষऔोञफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ भਈৗගदमؚ जोਰఋभଢ଼ટऋਸऔोथؚ /9() भਫଞৣ கऋधਝऔोञ؛(6& भ SRVLWLRQ SDSHU दमؚ &75&' भଝَ॑ /9() ऋঋش५ছॖ থे ॉु এॖ থॺ॑ தइथৣ खؚ
p.7
ऊणਫଞৣ க॑ৣ ॊُ धऔोथःॊऒधऊै /9() ऋঋش५ছॖ থे ॉु এॖ থॺ॑
தइथৣ खؚ ऊण॑ৣ ॊُ धऌप&75&' धଝऔोथऌञ؛खऊखؚ /9() पउऐॊෙ ୷ृؚ औै पम/9() भਫଞகऋदँ ॊऒधऊैؚ মু ਬऌदमَ /9() ऋঋش५ছॖ থे ॉु এॖ থॺ॑ தइथৣ खؚ ऊण/9() ऋ॑ৣ ॊُ धऌप&75&' धଝघॊऒधधखञ؛घ ऩॎठؚ /9()٫ڀ٫दँ ोयؚ ੦॑ ञघऋؚ /9()ڀ٫ؚ /9()٫ڀ٫दँ ोय੦ ॑ ञऔऩःऒधपऩॊ؛মᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ ভऋౣ ૐखञᇯᯂ୭ஓ൧ঁ থॻঈॵॡ মಏ ෫ᇯᯂ৾ ভभ2QFRFDUGLRORJ\ फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ दु /9() भৣ கम٫धऔोथउॉؚ ਠ૾ दमऋ॒
पൣ ढथ/9() ऋ٫॑ৣ ढञৃ়॑ &75&' ध൧घॊऒधऋः؛০ؚ ଢ଼ऋਤाग़অ ॹথ५ऋऔोॊऒधपे ॉؚ ऒभ੦கम৲घॊ૭ચਙऋँ ॊञीؚ॔ ॵউॹشॺऋਏदँ ॊ؛ ऽञؚ णभਯஊदનपীऐै ोॊॎऐदमऩःञीؚ ऒभ੦॑ ञखथःऩऎथुؚ /9() ऋৣ ൊपँ ोयؚ ইज़টش॔ ॵউ॑ ಢऎघॊऩनؚ ৰಏ෫दभฑໞऩৌૢ ऋਏदँ ॊ؛ E*/6
ॹॕ ५ॡ১पे ॊ/9() भੑ ෙ୷म৺दँ ॉ ঋش५ছॖ থऊै ٫ৣ धःअ
&75&' भ൧੦धಉखःऒधमؚ পऌऩਖਡदँ ॊ؝ગਠਙभਖऊैؚ /9() भகभॎङऊऩ ৲मङखु ઌभ৲धमइऩःऒधुँ ॉؚ ফؚ ५ঌॵॡঝॺছॵय़থॢ ১॑ ৷ःञ*/6 ऋਹ৷ औोॊे अपऩढञ؝*/6 मؚ /9()े ॉुੱ ൙૩॑ ২े ऎਫ਼লदऌؚ ऊणؚ ગਠਙपરोञఏ धखथؚ ৪भ୭ஓঢ়৴भफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ टऐदऩऎؚ ৪বᇯᯂ৾ ভभफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থदु जभઞ৷ ऋတऔोथःॊ؛ऒोपगथমಏ෫ᇯᯂ৾ ভभ2QFRFDUGLRORJ\ फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থपउःथु ऋ॒ ఇরभऩੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪपउऐॊ*/6 भੑ ऋൠऎတऔोथःॊ؝ऩउؚ মু ਬद म*/6 मബৌகद੶घॊ؝५ঌॵॡঝॺছॵय़থॢ ১पे ॊ*/6 ऋदऌॊ୭पऩःਝदमؚ */6 धगऎంশກ্ भੱ ൙ઽೠચ॑ ௬खञఏदँ ॊ0 ঔشॻ১दলखઽೠᄀၣఉ ق0$36(؟PLWUDODQQXODUSODQHV\VWROLFH[FXUVLRQكु खऎमੌ ௶ঃঝ५ॻউছ১पे ॊઽೠᄀ ၣఉઈச২ق6bكदभ௬ु တऔोथःॊ؛खऊखऩऋैؚ 0$36(ؚ 6bधु पؚ */6 भे अप ऋ॒ ఇ১पे ॊੱ ਙ॑ ਫ਼লघॊढ़ॵॺड़ইகऋோखऩःञीؚ கउे लঋش५ছॖ থகधૻ
ຎखथ෩ऩৣ ऋੳीै ोोयؚ ཎਙभంੱ ൙૩॑ ઑअधःअੰ पधनऽॊ؛ ⋇ੑ ্ ১
*/6 मؚੱ એقশກએؚ ᒷએؚ ᒷએكभੱ ఢपॎञॊॹشॱऊैؚ
ઃ੪५ঌॵॡঝॺছॵय़থॢ ১॑ ৷ःथಎ઼ पऔोञ९ইॺक़ख़॔ँ ॊःमੰ ෲ৷॥থআগشॱ شदੰ ෲघॊ؛ಹऩ९ইॺक़ख़॔ दमؚ ఏऩੱ ॔ উটشॳگએऊै ਛऔोञॢ টشং ঝ५ॺঞॖ থශभআشॡக॑ खञக॑ */6 धखथःॊ؛ঐॖ ॼ५கधखथলৡऔोॊৃ়ुँ ॊ ऋؚ মু ਬऌदमബৌகقউছ५கكधखथඞढञ؛५ॺঞॖ থੑ म52, भਝقੱ Ⴭડ৸ಽऩ नكृ ॺছॵय़থॢ ১पಎ઼ قঋথॲشكभ୷ऋँ ॊञीؚ भಎ઼ؚ ९ইॺक़ख़॔ द৽ૌ॑ ୯अऒ धऋਘऎတऔोॊ؛ ⋈੦க
p.8
মযभ*/6 भਫଞகमؚ 7DNLJLNXै भਾઔऋँ ॊ؛ऋ॒ ৫भ*/6ੑ पे ॊॖ
ঋথॺपणःथभਾઔ॑ पऽधीञ؛ऒोै भଢ଼द৷ःै ोञ*/6 भढ़ॵॺड़ইகमؚ ع٫दँ ढञ؝*/6 भਫଞৣ கधखथऋ৷ःै ोॊऒधऋःऒधऊैؚ मৈজ ५ॡदؚ عमੀୠधऔोॊ؛ಿ ऋ॒ දଖधૻ ຎखथؚಿ ऋ॒ දଖपঋش५ছॖ থधૻ ຎख*/6 ऋৼৌपਰৣ खञඪमق؟٫ڀ٫؟ৼৌप٫द੦॑ ञघؚ ٫ڀ٫؟ৼৌप٫द੦ञऔङكؚ ञधइથਔऩ/9() भৣ॑ ੳीऩऎथुؚ ऋ॒ ఇ ১पे ॊੱ ਙقཎਙभంੱ ൙૩ऋँ ॉكऋऽढथःॊधਖ਼घसऌधऔोथःॊ؛্ؚ
ऋ॒ ఇ১धૻ ຎखथؚ ऋ॒ ఇ১भ*/6 भৼৌऩৣ ऋदँ ोयؚ ऋ॒ ఇ ১पे ॊੱ ਙमੳीऩःقཎਙभంੱ ൙૩मऩखكधऔोथःॊ؛ LLంఁચ
ంఁચఏऋؚ &75&' भ൧ृ ৽ૌ௴ؚ पથ৷दँ ॊधःअॹشॱम࿅खः؛
खऊखؚ ใோभफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থपజढथؚৢ ଞभঝشॳথਫ਼ਪदষॎोॊ௺ଁ ऩంఁચ௬धजो प੦तऎంౄಓभ௬॑ ষअसऌदँ ॊ؛ऋ॒ ఇ১पൣ अଓัृౢ ৷قᚉဇؚৣ በऩनكद ੯ऋघॊञीؚ ంౄಓभप(Hb॑ ৷ःॊपି ਔ॑ ਏघॊ؛ంౄಓभಊमੱਂ
৸भோ॑ંྮ घॊञीؚ ਚৄ ऋ௴औोञৃ় पमؚ ඪ૾ ऋႀਙदऩऎधु ୭ஓఐୢ प॥থ १ঝॺघॊऒधऋऽखः؛ LLL కਃચधཡဿಓ
కਃચ௬ऋؚ &75&' भ൧पથ৷दँ ॊधःअॹشॱम࿅खः؛ॲ१ॳॽঈ॑ அिॳট३
থय़ॼش८༛૩ఇऩनཡဿਙཡৈഷಓभজ५ॡभँ ॊఇ॑ ৷ःॊৃ়ؚँ ॊःमؚ ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ഷዟ ඪऋઑॎोॊৃ় पमؚ కઽೠચभ௬ऋਏधऩॊ؛ऽञؚ 3770 قཡᇯᯂഷዟਙ৵ഷଵඪ 3XOPRQDU\WXPRUWKURPERWLFPLFURDQJLRSDWK\धःअਙཡৈഷಓඪ॑ ਟघऋ॒ ঢ়৴ႈ೩भ൧पुੱ
ग़॥شਫ਼ਪमથ৷दँ ॊ؛ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदؚ కఁপृ కઽೠચभৣ॑ ੳीञৃ়ؚँ ॊः मཡৈഷಓऋંྮ औोॊৃ় पमؚ ୭ஓఐषभ॥থ१ঝॺऋတऔोॊ؛ قڮكजभभॖ ওش४থॢ Lੱ ටறୢ৾ قੱ ൙३থॳॢ ছইॕ شك
ঐঝॳ।شॺੱ ਗ਼ੱ উشঝॖ ওش४থॢ ১पे ॉؚ /9() ऋदऌॊ؝ऒोमؚ P ॸ
ॡॿ३क़॑ ഷૉपહାऔचؚੱ ਗ਼॑ औचथ̤ ढ़ওছद୶खؚੱ ටभढ़क़থॺ॑ ষअ্ ১ दँ ॊ؛ম১॑ ৷ःथ৲৾ ১রभੱ ਃચঔॽॱজথॢ॑ ষअऒधऋदऌؚ $+$ق৪বੱ ටੈ ভ$&& ق৪বੱ ට୰৾ ভكभफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থदॡছ५⋛$ भిૢ धऔोथःॊ؛ੱ ਙभଫৄ पથ৷दँ ॊधःअਾઔुँ ॊ؛ગਠਙुे ऎؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪद/9() ऋ௬दऌऩःৃ় पથ৷दँ ॊऋؚ ᓄधৈःୢ ॥५ॺऋਂ ਹऩਡदँ ॊ؛ LLੱ ට05,
ਠؚ ంઍؚ /9() भੑ दम०شঝॻ५ॱথॲشॻधऔोॊਫ਼ਪदँ ॉؚ ਈु ਫનऩం
ઍऋ੭ै ोॊ؛ऽञؚੱ ට05, दमؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदमਂ ૭ચऩੱ ൙ਙ૾ भ௬ऋ૭ચदँ ॊ؛
p.9
ॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈ॑ ଖखञऋ॒ ೩पउःथؚ ంડपफ़ॻজॽक़భୗ୶ऋाै ोॊधःअਾ
ઔृ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথद॑ ਭऐञऋ॒ १ংॖ ংشभরपؚ 7 PDSSLQJ दৈਦಀ॑ં घཎ ऩੱ ൙૩॑ ਟखथःॊऋँ ॊधःअਾઔऋँ ॊ؛ੱ ට05, मؚ ᓄऋऩऎ৸ਙपરोؚ ਫન ਙؚ ગਠਙुे ःਫ਼ਪदँ ॉؚ &75&' भ൧ਰਗपु ऋ॒ भੱ ටषभဋृ ૡभ൧पु ৷ःै ोॊ؛ खऊखؚ ਫ਼ਪৎऋশःऒधृୢ ॥५ॺभਖऋँ ॉؚ ষदऌॊਝऋै ोथःॊ؛खञऋढथؚੱ
ग़॥شਫ਼ਪद/9() भ௬ऋऩৃ় पਫ਼ୈऔोॊसऌदँ ॊ؛ ਸ਼,,, ฆ ऋ॒ ఇ১॑ ষअ೩पৌघॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभউটॺ॥شঝ قڭكऋ॒ ఇ১भੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ
ऋ॒ भਫ਼ਪभ৯मؚੱ ഷଵ୰জ५ॡभ௬धؚ କऒॉ੭ॊੱ ഷଵ় ಡඪभؚ ऩै ल
प৽ૌपउऐॊੱ ഷଵ় ಡඪभଫ൧भञीभ॥থॺটشঝॹشॱ॑ ॊऒधदँ ॉؚ ৸थभੱ ਙभँ ॊऋ॒ भपमؚ ੦মपम৸पষअसऌदँ ॊ؛ৢ ଞभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदघॊඨ ৯म৸थඨ৯दँ ॊ؛્ पంฌল૨भੑ मऋ॒ ঢ়৴ੱ ൙૩भଝजभु भपु அऽोथ ःॊञीؚ ਈਏඨ৯दँ ॊ؛(6& फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থदम/9() भੑ म ઃ੪ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदੑ घॊ ऒधऋတऔोथःॊ؛ऽञؚ ంੱ ൙૩भे ॉོ สऩఏधखथ*/6 भੑ ऋတऔोथउॉ ऋ૭ચऩਝदम*/6ु ඨ৯दँ ॊ؛ पऋ॒ ఇ১॑ ষअ೩पৌघॊੱ ग़॥ش ਫ਼ਪभউটॺ॥شঝ॑ં खञ؛মউটॺ॥شঝम૮ඪਙभඪ॑ ୳खथःॊऋؚੱਂ ৸ඪ૾॑ ੳी ॊधऌृ ౯दऌऩःधऌؚ ऽञংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شق%1317SUR%13ؚ ॺটএॽথكऩनदੱਂ ৸॑ ઑअ धऌमి ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ୯ਸघॊऒध॑ တघॊ؛ प৻ऩಿ ऋ॒ දपउऐॊইज़টش॔ ॵ উ॑ં घ؛জ५ॡಽશ৲म+)$,&26 জ५ॡ५॥॔ ऩन॑ සघॊ؛
قڮكऋ॒ ఇ১রभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ قLكইज़টش॔ ॵউभᄄ২
থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ ऋ॒ දଖরपमؚ पં खञे अपؚ জ५ॡपૢ गथपੱ
ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ষअ؛ऽञؚ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ ऋ॒ දपे ॊੱ ൙૩म৷ൂ ோਙऋৄै ोॊञ ीؚ ؚ রজ५ॡदुؚ ଖऋॻय़९ঝঅ३থఌद ⋸P தइञৎपमੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ষःؚ ଖभ୯ਸपൣ ःইज़টش॔ ॵউभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ষअ؛ऽञؚ ୭ஓఐୢ ऋಿ ऋ॒ ද भଖऋཔखपऎःਠ૾ुँ ॉؚ जभৃ়ؚ ইज़টش॔ ॵউभ৯धखथؚ নাपڭங২ध खؚ ਝओधभ૾ யपૢ गथৠघॊ؛ਈु ਏऩऒधमؚ ਏऩইज़টش॔ ॵউऋ௷ऐठऩःे अप घॊऒधदँ ॊ؛্ दؚಿ +(5ಿ ৬ఇदँ ॊॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈभੱ ൙૩मؚ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ
ऋ॒ දधૻ ຎखथ৷ൂ ோਙऋाै ोऩःऒधऋः؛রमి ਫઞ৷फ़ॖ ॻप੶ൗऔोथःॊे अपؚ নাभইज़টش॔ ॵউऋऽखः؛ऽञؚ ৗૠఇදपुؚి ਫઞ৷फ़ॖ ॻपऒभे अऩইज़ টش॔ ॵউपঢ়घॊ੶ൗऋऩऔोथःॊ؛ञटखؚి ਫઞ৷फ़ॖ ॻप੶ൗभग़॥شတᄄ২मؚ ग़অॹথ ५भँ ॊु भयऊॉदमऩऎऎऋఇදभୡॹ२ॖ থभभੱ ग़॥ش५ॣ ४গشঝ॑ ৷खञु भ
p.10
दँ ॉؚి ਫઞ৷फ़ॖ ॻप੶ൗऔोथःॊᄄ২৸थदইज़টش॔ ॵউੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ষअऒधमਠৰ
दमऩः؛ৰಏ෫पउःथमؚ ಏ෫ඪ૾ লਠৎؚ ; ृ &7 दपૻ सथੱྔ ୶भఁপ ൊऋँ ॊधऌऩनؚ ಏ෫ਏऩৎपి ੱ ग़॥ش௬॑ અൟघॊ؛खञ&75&' भ੦॑ੂ ीथ ञखञৃ়ؚੱ ৳૧ఇभଖउे लಿ ऋ॒ දभಲਢभ૭౯पणःथؚ ऋ॒ ୢ ध୭ஓఐद৮ घॊ؛जभؚ ऩऎधुੂ मؚ ڮٕ گౝਰप২ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ইज़টشघॊ؛जभ୭ஓ ఐधऋ॒ ୢ दৼखऩऋैి ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ইज़টشखؚಿ ऋ॒ දभরطગ৫॑ ৠख थःऎ؛ قLLكਫ਼ਪඨ৯
রपষॎोॊਫ਼ਪभ৯मؚ &75&'॑ ଫपৄ खؚੱ ৳૧ఇभଖृ ঞ४ওথभ৹ତऩ
न॑ ষअऒधपे ॉؚ ૭ચऩॉऋ॒ पৌघॊ॑ ຄघॊऒधऋदऌॊे अपघॊऒधदँ ॊ؛ಿ ऋ॒ දরभইज़টش॔ ॵউੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभᄄ২मؚ ඨपં खञधउॉदँ ॊऋؚ घसथभ೩ पഡऩইज़টش॔ ॵউ॑ ষअऒधमਫ਼ਪभঐথঃডشभਡऊैु खः؛खञऋढथؚ ඨ৯ध खथम&75&' भଝपुৄै ोॊంઽೠચभ௬ؚ उे लੱਂ ৸भଫৄ पથ৷धऔोॊংॖ ड़ ঐشढ़شق%1317SUR%13ؚ ॺটএॽথكऩनभఏपघॊ؛नभఏपঢ়खथु கउे
लঋش५ছॖ থகधभૻ ຎऋਏदँ ॊ؛્ प*/6 म&75&' भଫৄ पથ৷धऔोथउॉؚ ऋ॒ ఇ১भகऊै জ५ॡ॑ ಽશ৲दऌॊधःअਾઔु ফऩऔोथःॊقك؛ قگكऋ॒ ఇ১ીവभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪقك قLইज़টش॔ ॵউभᄄ২ध
৵ుऩै लपਛয॑ ਖॎङؚಿ ऋ॒ දभઞ৷मেၺपॎञढथੱ ൙૩েभজ५ॡपऩॊध
ਾઔऔोथःॊ؛્ प॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ ऋ॒ ද॑ ઞ৷खञඪपঢ়खथमؚ भఇදधૻ ຎखथੱ
൙૩॑ েघॊન૨ऋৈऎؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪؚ ংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شऩन॑ ৷ःथؚ ऩইज़টشऋ ਏदँ ॊ؛॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ ऋ॒ දपे ॊੱ ൙૩भऋ ফਰपඪखؚ নাद ඪघॊधਾઔऔोथःॊभद ଖ৫ ऊাम્ पడऩইज़টشऋਏदँ ॊ؛ইज़টش॔ ॵ উીവभৎपঢ়खथमؚ ग़অॹথ५ऋऩःऋؚಿ ऋ॒ දরउे लपؚੱ ਃચৣ ऩनपे ॉੱ
৳૧ఇभଖृಿ ऋ॒ දউটॺ॥شঝभৄ ઉख॑ ষढञඪपঢ়खथमেၺभইज़টشق ফपڭ ங২॑ ৯؛ੱ ਃચृ ಏ෫ඪ૾ पૢ गथৠीॊكؚ রउे ल নাभਫ਼ਪदੱ ਃચप౮ଞ॑
ੳीऩऊढञඪदमؚ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ ऋ॒ දઞ৷भৃ় मીവ ফऽदইज़ট شखथ౮ଞऋऩऐोयইज़টش॔ ॵউીവधघॊ؛॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ಿ ऋ॒ ද॑ ઞ৷खथःऩःඪ भৃ় मીവभਫ਼ਪद౮ଞऋऩऐोयইज़টش॔ ॵউીവधघॊ؛ञटखؚ ऋै ोञਤ ষऋ॒ भ೩पੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभইज़টش॑ िृ ापಲਢघॊभमి જदमऩःभदؚ ऋ॒ भਤষ২ृ ॑ ༓ाथશ৲घसऌदँ ॊ؛ قLLكਫ਼ਪඨ৯
भইज़টش॔ ॵউਫ਼ਪपঢ়खथमؚ भਫ਼ਪधؚৢ ଞभੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदघ
ॊඨ৯॑ घसथੑ घॊ؛ऽञ*/6 भੑ पঢ়खथु दँ ॊ؛
p.11
ਸ਼,9 ฆ ඊႵॳख़ॵॡএॖ থॺ༛૩ఇपे ॊੱ ഷଵ૩
قڭك
ऋ॒ ඊႵ১भனपे ॉؚ ,&,V मऎभऋ॒ ரपउःथभ৭උ࿔धऩढथःॊ؛,&,V पे ॉಿ ᇯᯂඊႵऋણਙ৲औोॊऋؚ ৸ମभऔऽकऽऩටஓदभঽഞඊႵሤણ৲ऋਉधઅइै ोॊඊႵ ঢ়৴થ૩হभেऋି ৯औोथउॉؚ ऩऊदुੱ ਙमಱଈधऩॉ੭ॊ় ಡඪदँ ॊ؛,&,V पे ॊੱ
ਙमੱ ൙༇ؚੱ Ⴭ༇ؚ ञऒणऻඪණؚ శ༇ඪਙੱਂ ৸ؚ ཡৈഷಓඪऩनวपॎञॊ؛ളਯभ,&,V॑ ಡ৷घॊৃ়ؚ ද১े ॉुੱ ൙༇भඪ૨ऋৈऎऩॊ؛,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇मඪᄄ২tध ወदँ ॊऋؚ ಱଈ૨मtधৈऎؚ ଫ൧धஂ োऋாीथਏदँ ॊ؛৷శൂ ோਙपඪ खؚ ,&,V भੂ ଖऊै ඪऽदभम ধাਰऋः؛൱؞ళล؞ᠶ؞ଷઋऩनभඪ૾ ऋँ ॊऋؚ ඪ૾ ऋశ્ ౮ऩৃ়ुँ ॊभदି ਔऋਏदँ ॊ؛ قڮك,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भੱ ग़॥شਚৄ
,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇્ થभੱ ग़॥شਚৄ धःअु भमऩः؛ಹपਙੱ ൙༇दमؚੱ ൙भ༇
ඪਜ਼पಱखञෝௐधઈৣؚੱ ᒷभ৵৲ੱ Ⴭั ฅ॑ ੳीॊ؛ంઈमੱ ൙भ༇ ඪऋઁ ೧पवৃ় पमलऽ॒ ਙपৣ घॊऋ༇ඪऋଂਚऩৃ় मଂਚઈ౮ଞ॑ Ⴋघॊ؝ ంઈৣ ऋ৯য়ञऩःৃ় पउःथु जभपౕ पઈऋப৲घॊৃ় ऋँ ॊभदؚ ৽ৎ ऩইज़টشऋਏदँ ॊ؛ऽञؚ కਃચभ௬ु ਏदँ ॊ؛ੱ ൙༇भরपमక॑ રਜ਼प૩घॊु
भऋँ ॉؚ క)$&قIUDFWLRQDODUHDFKDQJHكृ7$36(قWULFXVSLGDQQXODUSODQHV\VWROLFH[FXUVLRQك भ௬ऋऽखः؛ قگك,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भ൧੦
,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भಏ෫൧पमؚ ഷরॺটএॽথகभથਔऩಊपਸइथؚ ਏ੦ ඨ৯ऽ
ञमౢ ੦ ඨ৯ਰ॑ ञघਏऋँ ॊقؚ ڲك؛ੱ ൙༇भ൧पमؚ ॺটএॽথभपमੱ ൙્ ౮ਙभৈःؚ ৈ২ॺটএॽথ,قKV7Q,كऋတऔोणणँ ॉؚ */6 भ৲धੌ ा় ॎचॊऒध दଫ൧षभ൴ऋୄ औोॊ؛,&,V ଫभ*/6 भৣ मؚ KV7Q, भಊपથਔऩঢ়৴ऋँ ॉؚ ଫੱ ൙૩भఏधऩॊ૭ચਙऋંྮ औोथःॊ؛ قڰكੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪधঔॲজॸॕ धभଁ় ௬ੱ
ग़॥شਫ਼ਪमලਙ؞శਙपરोॊ্ द્ؚ ౮২भએदमੀऋँ ॊ؛ੱ ට05, म
77PDSSLQJृ फ़ॻজॽक़భୗ୶पे ॉੱ ൙༇भ൧पउःथરोॊऋؚ ೄඪदमྔ ਙधऩॊ ऒधुँ ॊ؛ऽञؚ )'* 3(7&7 ਫ਼ਪ॑ జਟਫ਼ਪ১धੌ ा় ॎचॊऒधदੱ ൙༇भણਙृ ೧भ௬ ऋदऌॊटऐदऩऎؚ ટभਖ਼पु થ৷दँ ॊ૭ચਙऋँ ॊ؛*D'27$72&3(7&7 ऩनৗ ञऩறୢ৾ ু ১ु ৫औोणणँ ॉؚ ऒोै धभੌ ा় ॎचपे ॊঐঝॳঔॲজॸॕ ௬ऋတऔो ॊ؛ قڱك,&,V ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भ
ऽङఇද॑ রૃ भअइؚ ५ॸটॖ ॻঃঝ५১॑ ষःؚ जभ৽ઠউঞॻॽ॰টথपಌखؚ ඪ
p.12
ॺটএॽথகؚੱ ਃચؚਂ ତဿऩनभ୮॑ નੳखऩऋै ሰघॊ؛५ॸটॖ ॻಿ ਙभৃ়ृ แඪ
ੱ ൙༇पৌघॊઃधखथളਯभඊႵ೪ঞ४ওথऋਫ਼औोथःॊऋؚ ਠৎਡदग़অॹথ५म ࿅खः؛ ਸ਼9 ฆ ऋ॒ पൣ अजभभ় ಡඪੱ ग़॥شपे ॊ௬धৌૢ قڭكཡৈഷಓඪ
ཡৈഷಓඪق3+SXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQكमؚ ಹपਸ਼ ණقంੱਂ ৸पे ॊ3+كभᄄ
২ऋৈः ऋؚ ᇯᯂ୭ஓ୩ୠपउःथम౮ऩॊ୰ଙ॑ खयखय৽ୡघॊ؛ཡဿഷዟኋዟඪق37(كؚ ऋ॒ ఇ১पे ॊ3+ؚ 3770ؚ ཿਙᇈੜ༢ਙႈ೩قཿਙᇈਙஜഷ୰ऩनك पे ॊ3+ दँ ॊ؛ मऋ॒ जभु भपे ॊ3+ दँ ॊقਸ਼ థك भदؚ ऒऒदमસఎघॊ؛ऩउؚ ཡഷଵᇯقਸ਼ థपীథऔोॊكؚ জথঃဿଵ൙ᇯඪق/$0؟O\PSKDQJLROHLRP\RPDWRVLVكقਸ਼ థكؚ ഷଵপཝ % ཝਙজথঃᇯु 3+॑ ਬऌକऒघወऩႈ೩दँ ॊ؛37( म&$7قFDQFHU DVVRFLDWHG WKURPERVLV ऋ॒ ঢ়৴ഷዟඪكभฮधखथऋ॒ पे ॊૌᅼಕपे ॉಡघॊऒधऋँ ॊऋؚ ऋ॒ ఇ১भౢ ৷ धखथु ੴै ोथउॉؚ ৻ऩఇදम३५উছॳথؚ ഷଵৗে༛૩දقঋং३६ঐঈऩनكؚ ,&,V दँ ॊ؛ऒोै॑ ৷ःञঞ४ওথदमಯဿഷዟඪ॑ ಡघॊऒधऋँ ॉؚ ཡৈഷಓඪपे ॊకੱ ؞కੱ ਃ ચৣ ऋ২भৃ় मঞ४ওথಌऋਫ਼ୈऔोॊऒधुँ ॊ؛ऋ॒ ఇ১पे ॊ3+ म'3$+ق'UXJ LQGXFHGSXOPRQDU\DUWHULDOK\SHUWHQVLRQكधखथਸ਼ ණपীథऔोॊقك؛&75&' धप 3+ भਉऋളघॊඪु धऌप৽ୡऔोॊऋؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदभਕఉಗআشॡഷசे ॉ3+॑
ੳीञৃ় म૭ચऩॉා॑ અघॊधधु पਏऋँ ोयؚ ऋ॒ प੍ ॑ ऌञऔऩः೧द ಖഡਫ਼ਪ॑ ਫ਼ୈघॊ؛ قڮكञऒणऻඪණ
ऋ॒ ೩मઔੴपे ॊಖઋ५ॺঞ५ऊै ञऒणऻඪණ॑ ಡघॊऒधऋँ ॊ؛ऽञؚ ऋ॒ ఇ১पे ॊञऒणऻඪණु ৽ୡऔोؚ )8ؚ ढ़ঌ३ॱঅথؚ ঋং३६ঐঈؚ ॥থঈঞ५ॱॳথ قমഺदमಏ෫ઞ৷كؚ জॶय़३ঐঈؚ ॳট३থय़ॼش८༛૩දؚ ,&,V ड़३ওঝॳॽঈ ऩनदਾ ઔऋँ ॊ؛ ਸ਼9, ฆ ଣೝभੱ ഷଵႈ೩ قڭك
قంउे लອ࿒كपৌघॊଣೝमؚ பਙজথঃᇯृ ऋؚ॒ ཡऋؚ॒ ୫ऋ॒ ऩ
नदষॎोथःॊ؛ऊणथमଣೝपे ॊੱ ටृ ഷଵपৌघॊ୶मऩःधऔोथःञऋؚ ऋ॒ भਤనपൣ ःশেோऋੜइॊधؚྻ ਙ় ಡඪधखथੱ ഷଵႈ೩ऋඪघॊऒधऋীऊॉି ৯ औोथःॊ؛ଣೝभසೝ೧पे ढथੱ Ⴭ༇ृੱ ൙ඪؚ ఉჍඪؚ ་ဿႈ೩ऩन॑ ඪघॊ૭ચਙ ऋँ ॉؚ f ফदfपඪघॊधऔोॊऋؚ ႈ೩पे ढथमਯે ফपඪखਂ ଐ भधऩॊञीؚे ॉশऩইज़টش॔ ॵউऋਏदँ ॊ؛5,+' ඪभ૫धखथमؚ ফ
p.13
ؚ ଣೝऋৈःؚ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇදभઞ৷ऩनऋँ ॉقك ૫॑ થघॊৃ়
म્ पି ਔऋਏदँ ॊ؛ قڮك قLكੱ Ⴭႈ೩
ਙੱ Ⴭ༇मଣೝभਙ় ಡඪदँ ॊऋؚ සೝभृ සೝ೧भచदᄄ২म
ৣ खथःॊ؛ଣೝभਯౝऊै ਯফपमཿਙੱ Ⴭ༇ऋেगؚੱ Ⴭभਙෝௐؚ Ⴉାउे लཿਙੱ Ⴭั ฅ॑ ੳीؚ ઽೠਙੱ Ⴭ༇॑ ඪघॊऒधऋँ ॊ؛ઽೠਙੱ Ⴭ༇मع٫ங২पੳीै ोؚ සೝऋੜइॊधඪᄄ২ु ੜਸघॊ؛ قLLੱ ൙૩
൙ཝঽ৬मཝীຝ॑ କऒऔऩःञीଣೝपৌखथິ ਙ॑ णधऔोॊऋؚ ഷଵຜम૩॑ ਭ ऐॊ؛जभञी৵ഷଵ૩पे ॊ༘ ഷऋেगॊऒधपे ढथؚੱ ൙ႈ೩॑ ඪघॊधऔोॊ؛ੱ ൙ସ भ৲भਤষपൣ ढथੱ ൙भ॥থউছॖ॔ থ५ऋৣ घॊञीؚ ఁਃચৣ ऋ৬धऩॊऋؚ ઽೠ ਃચৣ॑ ਟघऒधुँ ॊ؛ඵౕ ௺ऋ૩॑ ਭऐॊऒधुँ ॊ؛ඪमங২धऔोथःॊऋ ؚ ४य़থজথঃᇯपৌघॊଣೝभੱ ൙૩॑ ৹ਪखञਾઔदमؚ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇද॑
ಡ৷खऩऊढञৃ় दुؚ ফभྸ ੱਂ ৸ඪ૨मؚ *\ दؚ *\ दؚ *\ ਰदधൂ ோਙपੜਸघॊऒधऋં औोथःॊ؛ قLLL ఉჍඪ
ଣೝभ୶दؚ ఉृ ఉఢ೧ੌ ௶पෝௐृ ৲ؚ ಢೠؚ લ࿏৲ऋেगॊ؛కੱ ௺े ॉु
ంੱ ௺पःऒधऊैؚ ඪपमಓऋঢ়ଖघॊधऔोथःॊ؛ఉഈृ ઐ৴भਙऋऩःऒ धृؚ ষপဿृ ఉपु લ࿏৲ऋवऒधऋজक़ঐॳਙ৲धम౮ऩॊ؛পဿصᄀၣఉਙ ৴ਢभෝௐृ લ࿏৲ऋؚ ଣೝഄभ્ ඉधऔोؚ जभங২मपঢ়৴खथःॊ؛ఉभಢೠऋ েगॊञीؚ ᒡඪे ॉु ಗऋেगॊऒधऋः؛ಏ෫पથਔऩఉჍႈ೩मؚ ଣೝ ফद ؚ ফदؚ ফदங২दँ ॉؚ ଣೝ ফदؚ ೄ২পဿఉಗऋؚ রಉ২ ਰभপဿఉಗऋؚ ೄ২عরಉ২भপဿఉᒡඪऋؚ ೄ২ᄀၣఉಗऋؚ ೄ২ཡ ဿఉಗऋங২धऔोथःॊ؛২भఉჍႈ೩दু ॑ ਫ਼ୈघॊৃ় मؚ ອ࿒भႩାؚ ཡभ ৲ृ ষপဿभલ࿏৲ऩन৫ੱ भজ५ॡऋৈःऒधुँ ॉؚ পဿఉᒡඪभৃ় पम৽ढ़ॸش ॸঝপဿఉ઼ ఌु ਫ਼ୈऔोॊ؛ قLY ་ဿႈ೩
ଣೝपे ॊ་ဿႈ೩मؚ ഷଵຜ૩पे ॉဿໂ৲ऋയਤघॊऒधदেगॊ؛
ফदႀ৲खؚ ফभ্ ऋৈೡे ॉु ඪखृ घः؛४य़থজথঃᇯपৌघॊଣೝ भ་ဿႈ೩॑ ৹ਪखञଢ଼दमؚ ফभৎਡदप་ဿ୰॑ ੳीञधਾઔऔोथ ःॊ؛་૫ऋःध୰ऋਤষखृ घऎؚ ంपଣೝසೝ॑ ਭऐॊంડऋ॒ ऩनदमؚ ం ་ဿୌृ ਜ਼भ୰ऋः؛৫ੱ मজ५ॡऋৈऎؚ ऽञؚ ढ़ॸشॸঝदमৢ ଞभဿ ໂ৲୰े ॉु ગᒡऋःधऔोؚ ిૢ मඦऩਖ਼ऋीै ोॊ؛
p.14
قگكଣೝभইज़টش॔ ॵউ
ଣೝؚ রपङखु ঝشॳথपੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑ ষअਏमऩःऋؚ पঢ়ख
थमؚ भे अपؚ ଣೝਙੱ ૩मऎभৃ় ਯফؚु खऎम ফਰभফা॑ ৽थऊै ႀ৲घ ॊऒधऋःञीؚ ऩ൧ऩै लपজ५ॡই॓ ॡॱشभ௬ऋਏदँ ॊقك؛ফमੱ ष भසೝमऔोथःॊु भभؚ জ५ॡपૢ गथؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪपे ॊऩশभইज़টش॔ ॵউऋਏदँ ॊ؛ ਸ਼ 9,, ฆੱ ग़॥شੑ पउऐॊৰಏ෫भି ਔਡ قڭكᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ भਤனधੱ ग़॥شभ૽ સ
০ऽदपؚੱ ग़॥شपे ॊ/9() उे ल*/6 मؚ &75&' भঔॽॱজথॢ पਂ ૭ಳऩఏ
धखथનয়औोञ؛ऒोै भఏभ৲मؚ ऋ॒ ೩भ্ ଉ॑ ంకघॊਏऩदँ ॊ؛ऋ॒ ೩ ऋ৸ऊणి જऩ॑ ਭऐॊऒधऋदऌॊे अपؚੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪ॑૿ अमؚ जभಖ২ଵ৶पी ऩऐोयऩै ऩः؛ ফपऔोञَ মੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভಿ ऋ॒ දঢ়৴ੱ ൙૩भ൧पउऐ ॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभু ਬُ दमؚ ৰಏ෫पउऐॊੱ ग़॥شৰᄷभି ਔਡधಖ২ছॖ থपणःथसञ؛ खऊखؚ जोਰఋु ৗञऩऋ॒ ఇ১્ؚ प,&,V ऋಏ෫भৃ दઁ ऎ৷ःै ोॊे अपऩॉؚ जोपൣ अੱ ਙभ୰ଙृ ௬১पঢ়घॊੴৄ ऋऽढञ؛ऽञؚ যੵ ੴચق$,؟$UWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFHك॑ मग ीधघॊૼ ৗपे ॉؚੱ ग़॥شभੑ ಖ২ध૨ਙमఄ ඩपखणणँ ॊ؛औै पؚ ফ पम(6& फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ ऩनؚ বऩ৾ ভऊैु ৗञऩတऋં औोथःॊ؛ऒऒदमؚ ফ ගু ਬभတহඨ॑ ગਫ਼खؚ ਈभੴৄ॑ ਸइथؚ ৰಏ෫पउऐॊੱ ग़॥شभಖ২ؚ ગਠਙؚ उे ल થ৷ਙ॑ औै पৈीॊञीभ্ ১पणःथसॊ؛ قڮك&75&' भঔॽॱজথॢ ఏधಖ২ଵ৶भਏਙ
ग़॥شपे ॊ/9() उे ल*/6 मؚ &75&' भঔॽॱজথॢ पਂ ૭ಳऩఏधखथનয়औ
ोथःॊ্ दؚ जभગਠਙقੑ भयै णऌكपमି ਔऋਏदँ ॊ؛ফभਾઔदुؚ /9() भਫ਼ ؞ਫ਼ෙ୷म৺عங২ दँ ॉؚ */6 पणःथु ৺ங২ भෙ୷ऋেगॊधऔोथ ःॊ؛*/6 म/9()े ॉु &75&' भଫৄ पથ৷ऩఏदँ ॉؚ ગਠਙपु રोॊऒधऊैؚ (6& ऩनবफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থदुੱ ൙૩भଫਫ਼ল৯द*/6 ऋတऔोथःॊ؛ु ढधुؚ ऒोै भ ગਠਙपणःथभਾઔभऎमؚે ীऩੱ ग़॥شभ৽ୡधૼ ॑ ਏघॊਝऊै दँ ॉؚ ಹऩ র୰ृ ൧ਚदगગਠਙ॑૿ ৳दऌॊधमै ऩः؛્ पؚ /9() भ٫भෙ୷म&75&' भ൧ ੦पु ୶घॊகदँ ॊऒधपି ਔखऩऎथमऩै ऩः؛ৰಏ෫दमؚ ৵औऩ/9() ৲ق ऩनكमੑ ෙ୷भ೧दँ ॊ૭ચਙ॑ ୍ प઼ ऌؚ */6 भ৲ु અൟखथ় ऩਖ਼॑ ষअਏ ऋँ ॊ؛ قگكੱ ग़॥شಖ২ଵ৶भञीभதఠణਫ਼ਪपउऐॊ৳ஹधઇقك
ऽङதఠణ൧ಎ઼ ऋి ਫप૭खथੑ ऋষॎोॊञीपुؚ தఠణਫ਼ਪउे लਃஓଵ৶
पणःथमؚ फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থपปढञ৳ஹਡਫ਼॑ ষअऒधऋीै ोॊ؛ੱ ग़॥شੑ கभಖ২॑૿ ৳
p.15
घॊपमؚ ऩऎधु ফपम/9()ृ */6 भਫ਼ऩै लपਫ਼ෙ୷॑ નੳखؚ ਝधखथभ
ಖ২ଵ৶पीॊऒध॑ တघॊ؛ऽञؚੱ ग़॥شੑ भಖ২॑૿ ৳घॊञीपमؚ ५ॱॵইभઇऋ୦े
ॉु ਏदँ ॊ؛৽ୡभฒःਫ਼पणःथमؚੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভੳ௧ૼ పृ ௧ୢ ऩन৽ୡ॑ે ী प॒ टऋઇपਊञॉؚ ਫ਼ਪ૿ ਊऋगे अपಖ২ଐऎੑ ॑ ষइॊे अ॑ ষअ؛औै पؚੱ ग़॥شभಯૃ ऩै लपमःणदु සदऌॊे अप൸१شংشप৳ோखؚి ગੑ ॑ ষइ ॊे अਝ॑ ତइॊऒधऋऽखः؛ قڰكੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪपउऐॊਔਡقك
ग़॥شఏभੑ ෙ୷॑ লਟॊटऐ৵औऎघॊऒधऋؚి જऩ্ ଉৠपमਏदँ
ॊ؛ి જऩੑ க॑ घॊञीपुؚ ઃभਡपਔखथਫ਼ਪपँ ञॊਏऋँ ॊ؛ L ੑ க؞ঋش५ছॖ থੑ கभનੳ
ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभষഄऋँ ॊඪपउःथमؚ ਫ਼ਪपउे लঋش५ছॖ থभੑ கऩै
लप൸भનੳ॑ ষअ؛जभञीपुؚ ঋش५ছॖ থभ൸मङ੶ஈखथउऎ؛ે ীऩੱ ग़॥ش भ৽ୡ॑ ॒ टऋؚ ൸धૻ ຎखथभੑ கऋ༜ਊदऩःधਖ਼खञৃ় पमગੑ ॑ ষःؚ ୢ ष৴൪॑ ষअ؛ LL गਫ਼पे ॊੑ
૭ચदँ ोयؚ ඪपणःथमगਫ਼ऋॉନखਫ਼ਪ॑૿ ਊघॊऒधऋऽखः؛ञट
खؚ ਝभয৩ଦ઼ भਡऊै ऩৃ় मؚ ऒभॉदमऩः؛ LLL गਃஓपे ॊੑ
प*/6 भੑ पঢ়खथमؚ ঋথॲشदੑ கपୀःऋँ ॊऒधऋਾઔऔोथःॊ؛$6(
उे ल($&9, ऋघॊॱ५ॡইज़ش५ऩनपे ढथఏ৲ऋਤीै ोؚ ਠमঋথॲشभੰ ෲટ भयै णऌऋఒखञ ऋؚ ඪभੑ पणःथमؚ ૭ચऩ೧दगওشढ़شभதఠణ൧ಎ઼ दਫ਼ਪघॊऒधऋऽखः؛ञटखؚ ਝभৱ౫भਡऊै ऩৃ় मؚ ऒभॉदमऩः؛ LYੑ கभ༜ਊਙपणःथभનੳ
ग़॥شੑ கपणःथमؚે ীऩ৽ୡ॑ ॒ टਫ਼ऋଳಁ ऩ௬धಱखथःॊऊનੳ॑
ষअ؛૭ચदँ ोयؚ ਫ਼पਸइथु अभੱ ग़॥ش௧ୢँ ॊःमੳ௧ૼ పऋؚੑ கऋ༜ ਊऊ౯ऊનੳघॊऒधऋऽखः؛ੱ ग़॥شষഄऋँ ॊඪपउःथमؚੱ ग़॥شभੑ கभ ৲ऋؚ ൸भଳಁ ऩ৲धಱखथःॊऊનੳघॊ؛ قڱك$, भણ৷
ফؚ /9() उे ल*/6 भੑ पउःथؚ $, पे ॊঽੑ ૼ मু ੑ धૻ ຎखथৈःಖ
২धરोञગਠਙ॑ં घऒधऋऎभଢ଼दਾઔऔोथःॊ؛$, पे ॊঽੑ भোपे ढथੑ ৎभಢೠधਫ਼ਪૼ పभਜ૿ ೄऋৰਠखؚ ডشॡইটشऋ૨৲खथؚे ॉऎभਫ਼ਪ॑ ૨ पষअऒधऋदऌॊ૭ચਙऋँ ॊ؛ ্ दؚ जभੑ ટभ༜ਊਙपणःथमؚ ൸ृ ೩ੲਾधසै
ख় ॎचऩऋै ় पਖ਼दऌॊੱ ग़॥ش௧ୢृ ੳ௧ૼ పभଵ৶ऋਏदँ ॊ؛ऽञؚ ज भੑ ಖ২पणःथે ীऩਫ਼॑ औोञ$,ੑ ९ইॺभઞ৷॑ တघॊ؛
p.16
قڲكگ'ੱ ग़॥شभણ৷
گ'ੱ ग़॥شमؚ ڮ'ੱ ग़॥شे ॉु ਫનप/9()॑ লघॊऒधऋ૭ચदँ ॊ؛ੑ
९ইॺृ ਃஓোभ॥५ॺभએऊैؚ گ'ੱ ग़॥شऋऋবभಏ෫पે ীஉહःञधमइऩःऋؚ گ'ੱ ग़॥شभણ৷ु /9()ੑ भಖ২भञीपमથ৷दँ ॊ؛ قڳكੱ ग़॥شઈிભ
ऒऒऽदؚੱ ग़॥شभಖ২ଵ৶पਏऩઇृ ३५ॸؚ ਃஓଵ৶पणःथसथऌञ؛ਈु
ਏऩऒधमؚે ীऩ५य़ঝधੴ॑ થघॊੱ ग़॥ش௧ୢँ ॊःमੳ௧ૼ పऋிભधखथੱ ग़॥شभઈपँ ञॊऒधदँ ॊ؛ৗञऩಿ ऋ॒ දभఃৃृ ੴৄ भाबधુ पؚ &75&' पउऐॊੱ
ग़॥ش௬मਠु ਤనखਢऐथःॊ؛ிભमؚ ଞपੴ॑॔ ॵউॹشॺखऩऋैؚ ிભ॑ु ढथੱ ग़॥شभઈपਊञै ऩऐोयऩै ऩः؛
p.17
અધ൴
মੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভ ಿ ऋ॒ දঢ়৴ੱ ൙૩भ൧पउऐॊੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभু ਬ
/\RQ $5 /RSH])HUQDQGH] 7 &RXFK /6 HW DO (6& *XLGHOLQHV RQ FDUGLR
RQFRORJ\ GHYHORSHG LQ FROODERUDWLRQ ZLWK WKH (XURSHDQ +HPDWRORJ\ $VVRFLDWLRQ
(+$WKH(XURSHDQ6RFLHW\IRU7KHUDSHXWLF5DGLRORJ\DQG2QFRORJ\(6752DQG
WKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO&DUGLR2QFRORJ\6RFLHW\,&26(XU+HDUW-
মಏ෫ᇯᯂ৾ ভমᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ ভ2QFRFDUGLRORJ\ फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ વൡ
মಏ෫ᇯᯂଢ଼ॢ ঝشউ&RPPRQ7HUPLQRORJ\&ULWHULDIRU$GYHUVH(YHQWV&7&$(
YHUVLRQ
6ODPRQ'-/H\ODQG-RQHV%6KDN6HWDO8VHRIFKHPRWKHUDS\SOXVDPRQRFORQDO
DQWLERG\DJDLQVW+(5IRUPHWDVWDWLFEUHDVWFDQFHUWKDWRYHUH[SUHVVHV+(51(QJO
-0HG
-H\DSUDNDVK 3 6DQJKD 6 (OOHQEHUJHU . HW DO &DUGLRWR[LF (IIHFW RI 0RGHUQ
$QWKUDF\FOLQH'RVLQJRQ/HIW9HQWULFXODU(MHFWLRQ)UDFWLRQ$6\VWHPDWLF5HYLHZDQG
0HWD$QDO\VLVRI3ODFHER$UPV)URP5DQGRPL]HG&RQWUROOHG7ULDOV-$P+HDUW$VVRF
H
&DUGLQDOH ' &RORPER $ %DFFKLDQL * HW DO (DUO\ GHWHFWLRQ RI DQWKUDF\FOLQH
FDUGLRWR[LFLW\ DQG LPSURYHPHQW ZLWK KHDUW IDLOXUH WKHUDS\ &LUFXODWLRQ
p.18
&DUGLQDOH'&RORPER$/DPDQWLD*HWDO$QWKUDF\FOLQHLQGXFHGFDUGLRP\RSDWK\
FOLQLFDO UHOHYDQFH DQG UHVSRQVH WR SKDUPDFRORJLF WKHUDS\ - $P &ROO &DUGLRO
.LWDL7.RKVDND6.DWR7HWDO-&6-+)6*XLGHOLQHRQ'LDJQRVLVDQG7UHDWPHQW
RI+HDUW)DLOXUH&LUF-
$PHULFDQ&ROOHJHRI&DUGLRORJ\)RXQGDWLRQ$SSURSULDWH8VH&ULWHULD7DVN)$PHULFDQ
6RFLHW\ RI ( $PHULFDQ +HDUW $ HW DO
$&&)$6($+$$61&+)6$+566&$,6&&06&&76&05 $SSURSULDWH 8VH
&ULWHULD IRU (FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ $ 5HSRUW RI WKH $PHULFDQ &ROOHJH RI &DUGLRORJ\
)RXQGDWLRQ $SSURSULDWH 8VH &ULWHULD 7DVN )RUFH $PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI
(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ $PHULFDQ +HDUW $VVRFLDWLRQ $PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI 1XFOHDU
&DUGLRORJ\ +HDUW )DLOXUH 6RFLHW\ RI $PHULFD +HDUW 5K\WKP 6RFLHW\ 6RFLHW\ IRU
&DUGLRYDVFXODU $QJLRJUDSK\ DQG ,QWHUYHQWLRQV 6RFLHW\ RI &ULWLFDO &DUH 0HGLFLQH
6RFLHW\ RI &DUGLRYDVFXODU &RPSXWHG 7RPRJUDSK\ 6RFLHW\ IRU &DUGLRYDVFXODU
0DJQHWLF5HVRQDQFH$PHULFDQ&ROOHJHRI&KHVW3K\VLFLDQV-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
&KHLWOLQ 0' $UPVWURQJ :) $XULJHPPD *3 HW DO $&&$+$$6( *XLGHOLQH
8SGDWHIRUWKH&OLQLFDO$SSOLFDWLRQRI(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\VXPPDU\DUWLFOH$UHSRUWRI
WKH $PHULFDQ &ROOHJH RI &DUGLRORJ\$PHULFDQ +HDUW $VVRFLDWLRQ 7DVN )RUFH RQ
p.19
3UDFWLFH*XLGHOLQHV$&&$+$$6(&RPPLWWHHWR8SGDWHWKH*XLGHOLQHVIRUWKH
&OLQLFDO$SSOLFDWLRQRI(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
'DKHU,1.LP&6DOHK55HWDO3UHYDOHQFHRIDEQRUPDOHFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFILQGLQJV
LQ FDQFHU SDWLHQWV D UHWURVSHFWLYH HYDOXDWLRQ RI HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ IRU LGHQWLI\LQJ
FDUGLDFDEQRUPDOLWLHVLQFDQFHUSDWLHQWV(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\
3ODQD-&*DOGHULVL0%DUDF$HWDO([SHUWFRQVHQVXVIRUPXOWLPRGDOLW\LPDJLQJ
HYDOXDWLRQ RI DGXOW SDWLHQWV GXULQJ DQG DIWHU FDQFHU WKHUDS\ D UHSRUW IURP WKH
$PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI (FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ DQG WKH (XURSHDQ $VVRFLDWLRQ RI
&DUGLRYDVFXODU,PDJLQJ(XU+HDUW-&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
:RRG3:&KR\-%1DQGD1&HWDO/HIWYHQWULFXODUHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQDQGYROXPHV
LWGHSHQGVRQWKHLPDJLQJPHWKRG(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\
0HGYHGRIVN\ ' 0RU$YL 9 %\NX , HW DO 7KUHH'LPHQVLRQDO (FKRFDUGLRJUDSKLF
$XWRPDWHG 4XDQWLILFDWLRQ RI /HIW +HDUW &KDPEHU 9ROXPHV 8VLQJ DQ $GDSWLYH
$QDO\WLFV$OJRULWKP)HDVLELOLW\DQG,PSDFWRI,PDJH4XDOLW\LQ1RQVHOHFWHG3DWLHQWV
-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
/DQJ 50 %DGDQR /3 0RU$YL 9 HW DO 5HFRPPHQGDWLRQV IRU FDUGLDF FKDPEHU
TXDQWLILFDWLRQE\HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\LQDGXOWVDQXSGDWHIURPWKH$PHULFDQ6RFLHW\
RI(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQGWKH(XURSHDQ$VVRFLDWLRQRI&DUGLRYDVFXODU,PDJLQJ(XU
+HDUW-&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
p.20
,VQHU-0)HUUDQV9-&RKHQ65HWDO&OLQLFDODQGPRUSKRORJLFFDUGLDFILQGLQJVDIWHU
DQWKUDF\FOLQH FKHPRWKHUDS\ $QDO\VLV RI SDWLHQWV VWXGLHG DW QHFURSV\ $P -
&DUGLRO
/DQJ 50 %LHULJ 0 'HYHUHX[ 5% HW DO 5HFRPPHQGDWLRQV IRU FKDPEHU
TXDQWLILFDWLRQDUHSRUWIURPWKH$PHULFDQ6RFLHW\RI(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\
V*XLGHOLQHV
DQG6WDQGDUGV&RPPLWWHHDQGWKH&KDPEHU4XDQWLILFDWLRQ:ULWLQJ*URXSGHYHORSHG
LQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWKWKH(XURSHDQ$VVRFLDWLRQRI(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DEUDQFKRIWKH
(XURSHDQ6RFLHW\RI&DUGLRORJ\-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
=DPRUDQR-//DQFHOORWWL35RGULJXH]0XQR]'HWDO(6&3RVLWLRQ3DSHURQ
FDQFHUWUHDWPHQWVDQGFDUGLRYDVFXODUWR[LFLW\GHYHORSHGXQGHUWKHDXVSLFHVRIWKH
(6&&RPPLWWHHIRU3UDFWLFH*XLGHOLQHV7KH7DVN)RUFHIRUFDQFHUWUHDWPHQWVDQG
FDUGLRYDVFXODU WR[LFLW\ RI WKH (XURSHDQ 6RFLHW\ RI &DUGLRORJ\ (6& (XU +HDUW -
*URXS(6&6'>(6&*XLGHOLQHVRQFDUGLRRQFRORJ\GHYHORSHGLQFROODERUDWLRQ
ZLWK WKH (XURSHDQ +HPDWRORJ\ $VVRFLDWLRQ (+$ WKH (XURSHDQ 6RFLHW\ IRU
7KHUDSHXWLF5DGLRORJ\DQG2QFRORJ\(6752DQGWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO&DUGLR2QFRORJ\
6RFLHW\,&26@*,WDO&DUGLRO5RPHHH
মᇯᯂ୭ஓ৾ ভౣ ૐ৩ভౣ ᇯᯂ୭ஓ൧ঁ থॻঈॵॡ ও४ढ़ঝঅগش
7KDYHQGLUDQDWKDQ3*UDQW$'1HJLVKL7HWDO5HSURGXFLELOLW\RIHFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLF
p.21
WHFKQLTXHV IRU VHTXHQWLDO DVVHVVPHQW RI OHIW YHQWULFXODU HMHFWLRQ IUDFWLRQ DQG
YROXPHVDSSOLFDWLRQWRSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJFDQFHUFKHPRWKHUDS\-$P&ROO&DUGLRO
7KRPDV -' (GYDUGVHQ 7 $EUDKDP 7 HW DO &OLQLFDO $SSOLFDWLRQV RI 6WUDLQ
(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ $ &OLQLFDO &RQVHQVXV 6WDWHPHQW )URP WKH $PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI
(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ 'HYHORSHG LQ &ROODERUDWLRQ :LWK WKH (XURSHDQ $VVRFLDWLRQ RI
&DUGLRYDVFXODU,PDJLQJRIWKH(XURSHDQ6RFLHW\RI&DUGLRORJ\-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
7DNLJLNX.7DNHXFKL0,]XPL&HWDO1RUPDOUDQJHRIOHIWYHQWULFXODUGLPHQVLRQDO
VWUDLQ-DSDQHVH8OWUDVRXQG6SHFNOH7UDFNLQJRIWKH/HIW9HQWULFOH-867,&(VWXG\
&LUF-
0RXVDYL17DQ7&$OL0HWDO(FKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFSDUDPHWHUVRIOHIWYHQWULFXODUVL]H
DQG IXQFWLRQ DV SUHGLFWRUV RI V\PSWRPDWLF KHDUW IDLOXUH LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK D OHIW
YHQWULFXODU HMHFWLRQ IUDFWLRQ RI WUHDWHG ZLWK DQWKUDF\FOLQHV (XU +HDUW -
&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
5KHD ,% 8SSXOXUL 6 6DZDGD 6 HW DO ,QFUHPHQWDO SURJQRVWLF YDOXH RI
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFVWUDLQDQGLWVDVVRFLDWLRQZLWKPRUWDOLW\LQFDQFHUSDWLHQWV-$P
6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
$OL07<XFHO(%RXUDV6HWDO0\RFDUGLDO6WUDLQ,V$VVRFLDWHGZLWK$GYHUVH&OLQLFDO
p.22
&DUGLDF (YHQWV LQ 3DWLHQWV 7UHDWHG ZLWK $QWKUDF\FOLQHV - $P 6RF (FKRFDUGLRJU
H
+DWD]DZD . 7DQDND + 1RQDND $ HW DO %DVHOLQH *OREDO /RQJLWXGLQDO6WUDLQ DV D
3UHGLFWRU RI /HIW 9HQWULFXODU '\VIXQFWLRQ DQG +RVSLWDOL]DWLRQ IRU +HDUW )DLOXUH RI
3DWLHQWV :LWK 0DOLJQDQW /\PSKRPD $IWHU $QWKUDF\FOLQH 7KHUDS\ &LUF -
$UDXMR*XWLHUUH] 5 &KLWWXUL .5 ;X - HW DO %DVHOLQH JOREDO ORQJLWXGLQDO VWUDLQ
SUHGLFWLYHRIDQWKUDF\FOLQHLQGXFHGFDUGLRWR[LFLW\&DUGLRRQFRORJ\
7KDYHQGLUDQDWKDQ 3 1HJLVKL 7 6RPHUVHW ( HW DO 6WUDLQ*XLGHG 0DQDJHPHQW RI
3RWHQWLDOO\&DUGLRWR[LF&DQFHU7KHUDS\-$P&ROO&DUGLRO
/LX=/LX0=KRQJ;HWDO*OREDOORQJLWXGLQDOVWUDLQDWPRQWKVDIWHUWKHUDS\FDQ
SUHGLFWODWHFDUGLRWR[LFLW\LQEUHDVWFDQFHU&DQFHU0HG
*RQJ))*UXQEODWW(9RVV:%HWDO$VWUDLQJXLGHGWULDORIFDUGLRSURWHFWLRQLQHDUO\
VWDJHEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWVRQDQWL+(5WKHUDS\3527(&7+(5&DUGLRRQFRORJ\
5LKDFNRYD(5LKDFHN0%RXFHN/HWDO8WLOLW\RIJOREDOORQJLWXGLQDOVWUDLQLQHDUO\
LGHQWLILFDWLRQ RI FKURQLF FDUGLRWR[LFLW\ LQ DV\PSWRPDWLF ORQJWHUP PDOLJQDQW
O\PSKRPD VXUYLYRUV ZLWK QRUPDO OHIW YHQWULFOH HMHFWLRQ IUDFWLRQ 6FL 5HS
p.23
1DJXHK6)6DQERUQ'<2K-.HWDO5HFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUWKH(YDOXDWLRQRI/HIW
9HQWULFXODU 'LDVWROLF )XQFWLRQ E\ (FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ DQG IRU +HDUW )DLOXUH :LWK
3UHVHUYHG (MHFWLRQ )UDFWLRQ 'LDJQRVLV $Q 8SGDWH )URP WKH $PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI
(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
&KRL%:%HUJHU+-6FKZDUW]3(HWDO6HULDOUDGLRQXFOLGHDVVHVVPHQWRIGR[RUXELFLQ
FDUGLRWR[LFLW\ LQ FDQFHU SDWLHQWV ZLWK DEQRUPDO EDVHOLQH UHVWLQJ OHIW YHQWULFXODU
SHUIRUPDQFH$P+HDUW-
+HQGHO 5& %HUPDQ '6 'L &DUOL 0) HW DO
$&&)$61&$&5$+$$6(6&&76&05610 DSSURSULDWH XVH FULWHULD IRU
FDUGLDF UDGLRQXFOLGH LPDJLQJ D UHSRUW RI WKH $PHULFDQ &ROOHJH RI &DUGLRORJ\
)RXQGDWLRQ $SSURSULDWH 8VH &ULWHULD 7DVN )RUFH WKH $PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI 1XFOHDU
&DUGLRORJ\WKH$PHULFDQ&ROOHJHRI5DGLRORJ\WKH$PHULFDQ+HDUW$VVRFLDWLRQWKH
$PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI (FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ WKH 6RFLHW\ RI &DUGLRYDVFXODU &RPSXWHG
7RPRJUDSK\WKH6RFLHW\IRU&DUGLRYDVFXODU0DJQHWLF5HVRQDQFHDQGWKH6RFLHW\RI
1XFOHDU0HGLFLQH&LUFXODWLRQH
1RXVLDLQHQ7-DQWXQHQ(9DQQLQHQ(HWDO(DUO\GHFOLQHLQOHIWYHQWULFXODUHMHFWLRQ
IUDFWLRQ SUHGLFWV GR[RUXELFLQ FDUGLRWR[LFLW\ LQ O\PSKRPD SDWLHQWV %U - &DQFHU
7KHFOLQLFDOUROHRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLQFDUGLRYDVFXODUGLVHDVH7DVN)RUFHRIWKH
p.24
(XURSHDQ6RFLHW\RI&DUGLRORJ\LQFROODERUDWLRQZLWKWKH$VVRFLDWLRQRI(XURSHDQ
3DHGLDWULF&DUGLRORJLVWV(XU+HDUW-
)DOODK5DG1:DONHU-5:DVVHI$HWDO7KHXWLOLW\RIFDUGLDFELRPDUNHUVWLVVXH
YHORFLW\DQGVWUDLQLPDJLQJDQGFDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLQSUHGLFWLQJ
HDUO\ OHIW YHQWULFXODU G\VIXQFWLRQ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK KXPDQ HSLGHUPDO JURZWK IDFWRU
UHFHSWRU,,SRVLWLYHEUHDVWFDQFHUWUHDWHGZLWKDGMXYDQWWUDVWX]XPDEWKHUDS\-$P
&ROO&DUGLRO
-RUGDQ -+ 9DVX 6 0RUJDQ 70 HW DO $QWKUDF\FOLQH$VVRFLDWHG 7 0DSSLQJ
&KDUDFWHULVWLFV $UH (OHYDWHG ,QGHSHQGHQW RI WKH 3UHVHQFH RI &DUGLRYDVFXODU
&RPRUELGLWLHVLQ&DQFHU6XUYLYRUV&LUF&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
/\RQ$5'HQW66WDQZD\6HWDO%DVHOLQHFDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNDVVHVVPHQWLQFDQFHU
SDWLHQWVVFKHGXOHGWRUHFHLYHFDUGLRWR[LFFDQFHUWKHUDSLHVDSRVLWLRQVWDWHPHQWDQG
QHZULVNDVVHVVPHQWWRROVIURPWKH&DUGLR2QFRORJ\6WXG\*URXSRIWKH+HDUW)DLOXUH
$VVRFLDWLRQ RI WKH (XURSHDQ 6RFLHW\ RI &DUGLRORJ\ LQ FROODERUDWLRQ ZLWK WKH
,QWHUQDWLRQDO&DUGLR2QFRORJ\6RFLHW\(XU-+HDUW)DLO
0HKWD/6:DWVRQ.(%DUDF$HWDO&DUGLRYDVFXODU'LVHDVHDQG%UHDVW&DQFHU
:KHUH 7KHVH (QWLWLHV ,QWHUVHFW $ 6FLHQWLILF 6WDWHPHQW )URP WKH $PHULFDQ +HDUW
$VVRFLDWLRQ&LUFXODWLRQHH
6WRGGDUG0)6HHJHU-/LGGHOO1(HWDO3URORQJDWLRQRILVRYROXPHWULFUHOD[DWLRQWLPH
p.25
DV DVVHVVHG E\ 'RSSOHU HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ SUHGLFWV GR[RUXELFLQLQGXFHG V\VWROLF
G\VIXQFWLRQLQKXPDQV-$P&ROO&DUGLRO
'RUXS , /HYLWW * 6XOOLYDQ , HW DO 3URVSHFWLYH ORQJLWXGLQDO DVVHVVPHQW RI ODWH
DQWKUDF\FOLQH FDUGLRWR[LFLW\ DIWHU FKLOGKRRG FDQFHU WKH UROH RI GLDVWROLF IXQFWLRQ
+HDUW
3ODQD-&*DOGHULVL0%DUDF$HWDO([SHUWFRQVHQVXVIRUPXOWLPRGDOLW\LPDJLQJ
HYDOXDWLRQ RI DGXOW SDWLHQWV GXULQJ DQG DIWHU FDQFHU WKHUDS\ D UHSRUW IURP WKH
$PHULFDQ 6RFLHW\ RI (FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ DQG WKH (XURSHDQ $VVRFLDWLRQ RI
&DUGLRYDVFXODU,PDJLQJ-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
'H 3HUQD 0/ 5LJDPRQWL ( =DQQRQL 5 HW DO ,PPXQH &KHFNSRLQW ,QKLELWRUV DQG
&DUGLRYDVFXODU$GYHUVH(YHQWV(6&+HDUW)DLO
1DJDL 7 ,QRPDWD 7 .RKQR 7 HW DO -&6 *XLGHOLQH RQ WKH 'LDJQRVLV DQG
7UHDWPHQWRI0\RFDUGLWLV&LUF-
7DPXUD<7DPXUD<7DNHPXUD5HWDO/RQJLWXGLQDO6WUDLQDQG7URSRQLQ,(OHYDWLRQ
LQ 3DWLHQWV 8QGHUJRLQJ ,PPXQH &KHFNSRLQW ,QKLELWRU 7KHUDS\ -$&& &DUGLR2QFRO
+XPEHUW0.RYDFV*+RHSHU00HWDO(6&(56*XLGHOLQHVIRUWKHGLDJQRVLV
DQGWUHDWPHQWRISXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQ(XU+HDUW-
/HLYD2/LX2.DQHOLGLV$HWDO%H\RQG7KURPERVLV3XOPRQDU\+\SHUWHQVLRQDQG
p.26
+HDUW)DLOXUHLQ3DWLHQWV:LWK0\HORSUROLIHUDWLYH1HRSODVPV-$&&&DUGLR2QFRORJ\
6WDWHRIWKH$UW5HYLHZ-$&&&DUGLR2QFRO
ম୭ஓ৾ ভমཡৈഷಓ؞ཡ୭৾ ভ ফၖග ཡഷዟኋዟඪ؞ಯဿഷዟඪ
उे लཡৈഷಓඪपঢ়घॊफ़ॖ ॻছॖ থ
6LQJK7.KDQ+*DPEOH'7HWDO7DNRWVXER6\QGURPH3DWKRSK\VLRORJ\(PHUJLQJ
&RQFHSWVDQG&OLQLFDO,PSOLFDWLRQV&LUFXODWLRQ
'HVDL $ 1RRU $ -RVKL 6 HW DO 7DNRWVXER FDUGLRP\RSDWK\ LQ FDQFHU SDWLHQWV
&DUGLRRQFRORJ\
)XNXGD < .DZD < 1RQDND $ HW DO 5HRFFXUUHQFH RI WDNRWVXER FDUGLRP\RSDWK\
LQGXFHGE\RVLPHUWLQLE$FDVHUHSRUW&OLQ&DVH5HSH
'HVDL0<:LQGHFNHU6/DQFHOORWWL3HWDO3UHYHQWLRQ'LDJQRVLVDQG0DQDJHPHQW
RI 5DGLDWLRQ$VVRFLDWHG &DUGLDF 'LVHDVH -$&& 6FLHQWLILF ([SHUW 3DQHO - $P &ROO
&DUGLRO
/DQFHOORWWL 3 1NRPR 97 %DGDQR /3 HW DO ([SHUW FRQVHQVXV IRU PXOWLPRGDOLW\
LPDJLQJHYDOXDWLRQRIFDUGLRYDVFXODUFRPSOLFDWLRQVRIUDGLRWKHUDS\LQDGXOWVDUHSRUW
IURPWKH(XURSHDQ$VVRFLDWLRQRI&DUGLRYDVFXODU,PDJLQJDQGWKH$PHULFDQ6RFLHW\
RI(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\(XU+HDUW-&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
-DZRUVNL&0DULDQL-$:KHHOHU*HWDO&DUGLDFFRPSOLFDWLRQVRIWKRUDFLFLUUDGLDWLRQ
-$P&ROO&DUGLRO
p.27
&KDQJ+02NZXRVD706FDUDEHOOL7HWDO&DUGLRYDVFXODU&RPSOLFDWLRQVRI&DQFHU
7KHUDS\%HVW3UDFWLFHVLQ'LDJQRVLV3UHYHQWLRQDQG0DQDJHPHQW3DUW-$P&ROO
&DUGLRO
YDQ1LPZHJHQ)$1WHQWDV*'DUE\6&HWDO5LVNRIKHDUWIDLOXUHLQVXUYLYRUVRI
+RGJNLQ O\PSKRPD HIIHFWV RI FDUGLDF H[SRVXUH WR UDGLDWLRQ DQG DQWKUDF\FOLQHV
%ORRG
'HVDL 0< :X : 0DVUL $ HW DO ,QFUHDVHG DRUWRPLWUDO FXUWDLQ WKLFNQHVV
LQGHSHQGHQWO\SUHGLFWVPRUWDOLW\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKUDGLDWLRQDVVRFLDWHGFDUGLDFGLVHDVH
XQGHUJRLQJFDUGLDFVXUJHU\$QQ7KRUDF6XUJ
'RQQHOODQ ( 3KHODQ ' 0F&DUWK\ &3 HW DO 5DGLDWLRQLQGXFHG KHDUW GLVHDVH $
SUDFWLFDOJXLGHWRGLDJQRVLVDQGPDQDJHPHQW&OHYH&OLQ-0HG
YDQ 1LPZHJHQ )$ 6FKDDSYHOG 0 &XWWHU '- HW DO 5DGLDWLRQ 'RVH5HVSRQVH
5HODWLRQVKLSIRU5LVNRI&RURQDU\+HDUW'LVHDVHLQ6XUYLYRUVRI+RGJNLQ/\PSKRPD
-&OLQ2QFRO
*URXS&V2/RQJ7HUP)ROORZ8S*XLGHOLQHVIRU6XUYLYRUVRI&KLOGKRRG$GROHVFHQW
DQG <RXQJ $GXOW &DQFHUV 9HUVLRQ 2FWREHU
KWWSZZZVXUYLYRUVKLSJXLGHOLQHVRUJ
*URWKXHV)6PLWK*&0RRQ-&HWDO&RPSDULVRQRILQWHUVWXG\UHSURGXFLELOLW\RI
FDUGLRYDVFXODU PDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH ZLWK WZRGLPHQVLRQDO HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ LQ
p.28
QRUPDOVXEMHFWVDQGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKKHDUWIDLOXUHRUOHIWYHQWULFXODUK\SHUWURSK\$P
-&DUGLRO
0DOP 6 )ULJVWDG 6 6DJEHUJ ( HW DO 5HDOWLPH VLPXOWDQHRXV WULSODQH FRQWUDVW
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ JLYHV UDSLG DFFXUDWH DQG UHSURGXFLEOH DVVHVVPHQW RI OHIW
YHQWULFXODUYROXPHVDQGHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQDFRPSDULVRQZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
LPDJLQJ-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
&KHQJ 6 /DUVRQ 0* 0F&DEH (/ HW DO 5HSURGXFLELOLW\ RI VSHFNOHWUDFNLQJEDVHG
VWUDLQPHDVXUHVRIOHIWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQLQDFRPPXQLW\EDVHGVWXG\-$P6RF
(FKRFDUGLRJUH
মੱ ग़॥ش৾ ভੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪपઞ৷घॊதఠణ൧ಎ઼ भଵ৶पঢ়घॊু ਬऌ؟
ফীၖග
)DUVDOLQRV .( 'DUDEDQ $0 8QOX 6 HW DO +HDGWR+HDG &RPSDULVRQ RI *OREDO
/RQJLWXGLQDO6WUDLQ0HDVXUHPHQWVDPRQJ1LQH'LIIHUHQW9HQGRUV7KH($&9,$6(
,QWHU9HQGRU&RPSDULVRQ6WXG\-$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJUH
%DOLQLVWHDQX$'XFKHQQH-3XYUH]$HWDO9HQGRUGLIIHUHQFHVLQ'VSHFNOHWUDFNLQJ
JOREDOORQJLWXGLQDOVWUDLQDQXSGDWHRQD\HDUVWDQGDUGL]DWLRQHIIRUW(XU+HDUW-
&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
.DJL\DPD1$EH<.XVXQRVH.HWDO0XOWLFHQWHUYDOLGDWLRQVWXG\IRUDXWRPDWHGOHIW
YHQWULFXODUHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQDVVHVVPHQWXVLQJDKDQGKHOGXOWUDVRXQGZLWKDUWLILFLDO
p.29
LQWHOOLJHQFH6FL5HS
2ODLVHQ66PLVWDG((VSHODQG7HWDO$XWRPDWLFPHDVXUHPHQWVRIOHIWYHQWULFXODU
YROXPHVDQGHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQE\DUWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFHFOLQLFDOYDOLGDWLRQLQUHDOWLPH
DQGODUJHGDWDEDVHV(XU+HDUW-&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
6DOWH ,0 2VWYLN $ 2ODLVHQ 6+ HW DO 'HHS /HDUQLQJ IRU ,PSURYHG 3UHFLVLRQ DQG
5HSURGXFLELOLW\RI/HIW9HQWULFXODU6WUDLQLQ(FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\$7HVW5HWHVW6WXG\-
$P6RF(FKRFDUGLRJU
6WRZHOO && +RZDUG -3 1J 7 HW DO 'LPHQVLRQDO (FKRFDUGLRJUDSKLF *OREDO
/RQJLWXGLQDO 6WUDLQ :LWK $UWLILFLDO ,QWHOOLJHQFH 8VLQJ 2SHQ 'DWD )URP D 8.:LGH
&ROODERUDWLYH-$&&&DUGLRYDVF,PDJLQJ
'RURV] -/ /H]RWWH '& :HLW]HQNDPS '$ HW DO 3HUIRUPDQFH RI GLPHQVLRQDO
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ LQ PHDVXULQJ OHIW YHQWULFXODU YROXPHV DQG HMHFWLRQ IUDFWLRQ D
V\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZDQGPHWDDQDO\VLV-$P&ROO&DUGLRO
p.30
ᚰẘᛶࡢ࠶ࡿࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲ㛤ጞ๓ࡢᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝ LVEF<50% LVEF≧50% GLS<18% ᚰƫ⬟పୗࡢ⢭ᰝࢆ足࠸ࠊᚲせᛂ ࡌ࡚ ᚰಖㆤ⸆ࡢᢞ࡞(o)ࢆ足࠸㸪ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲ㛤ጞࡢྍྰ ࢆ᳨ウ
ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲࢆ㛤ጞ ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲࢆ㛤ጞ㸪₯ᅾhᕥ ᐊ⦰ࡢཎᅉࢆ᳨ ⣴ࡍࡿ㸨ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲ୰ࡢᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࡣ⏝⸆ᛂࡌ࡚足࠺ (韭3ཧ↷) LVEF≧50% GLSࡢ᭷ព࡞పୗ࡞ࡋ CTRCD ࡢデ᩿ (韭2ཧ↷) ᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࡢࣇ࢛࣮ࣟ ࡣ ⏝⸆ᛂࡌ࡚足࠸ (韭3ཧ↷) ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲࡢ୰᩿ ࢆ᳨ウ
ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲࢆ⥅⥆
LVEF<50%
CTRCD ࡢデ᩿ (韭2ཧ↷) ᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࡢࣇ࢛࣮ࣟ ࡣ ⏝⸆ᛂࡌ࡚足࠺ (韭3ཧ↷)
GLS≧18% GLSࡀ࣮࣋ ࢫࣛ ࣥ aʾリットルࡋ࡚ ┦ᑐh15㸣ࢆ카࠼࡚ పୗ
ːΠρφϧγέϨρܧ߇͗ ΞࡐͲ ͅχΫλϩθερ ࢋྩ ྖ ͲΎΧϫʖֶؔ Νݗ౾͢ ͱΓ͏
ᅗ1 ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲࢆ足࠺ᝈ⪅ᑐࡍࡿᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࡢࣉࣟ ࢺࢥࣝ
p.31
ࣥ ࢺࣛ ࢧࢡࣜࣥ ⣔ᢠࡀࢇࢆྵ ࡲ࡞࠸ ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲ⤊ࡢᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝ GLSࡢ᭷ព࡞పୗ࡞ࡋ GLSࡀ࣮࣋ ࢫࣛ ࣥ aʾリットルࡋ࡚ ┦ᑐh15㸣ࢆ카࠼࡚ పୗ ᚰಖㆤ⸆ࡢᢞ
LVEF<50%
CTRCD ࡢデ᩿ (韭2ཧ↷) ᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࡢࣇ࢛࣮ࣟ ࡣ ⏝⸆ᛂࡌ࡚足࠺ (韭3ཧ↷)
ࣇ࢛࣮ࣟ ࢵࣉ⤊ ࣥ ࢺࣛ ࢧࢡࣜࣥ ⣔ᢠࡀࢇࢆྵ ࡴ ࡀࢇ⸆≀(o)ἲ⤊ࠊ⤊6᭶ᚋ㸪12 ᭶ᚋࡢᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࢆ᥎ዡ 12᭶ᚋGLSࡢ᭷ព࡞పୗࢆㄆ ࡵ࡞ࡅࢀࡤࣇ࢛࣮ࣟ ࢵࣉ⤊
LVEF≧50㸣GLSࡢ᭷ព࡞పୗ࡞ࡋ GLSࡀ࣮࣋ ࢫࣛ ࣥ aʾリットルࡋ࡚ ┦ᑐh15㸣ࢆ카࠼࡚ పୗ ᚰಖㆤ⸆ࡢᢞ
LVEF<50%
CTRCD ࡢデ᩿ (韭2ཧ↷) ᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝࡢࣇ࢛࣮ࣟ ࡣ ⏝⸆ᛂࡌ࡚足࠺ (韭3ཧ↷)
LVEF≧50㸣
p.32
ᨺᑕ⥺(o)
1ᖺࡈࡢ≧࣭サイクルయ᳨ ᰝ࣭ࣜ ࢫࢡࣇࢡࢱ࣮ ࡢホ౯
≧࡞ࡋ ≧࠶ࡾ
ᚰ࢚ ࢥ࣮ ᅗ᳨ ᰝ
카㧗ࣜ ࢫࢡ ୰➼ᗘࣜ ࢫࢡ
ऋ॒ ીവৎभজ५ॡಽશ৲
தৈজ५ॡ ؞0+'!*\
؞0+'ع*\ऊणॻय़९ঝঅ३থఌˀPJP
ৈজ५ॡ ؞0+'ع*\
؞0+'ع*\ऊणॻय़९ঝঅ३থఌˀPJP
রಉ২জ५ॡ ؞0+'ع*\
؞0+'*\ऊणॻय़९ঝঅ३থఌˀPJP
জ५ॡ ؞0+'*\ MHD(mean heart dose) 㸸ᖹᆒᚰ⮚⥺㔞࣭ MHDࡀ࡛᫂ ࠶ࡿሙྜ ࠊMHD>15Gyࡣᚰ⮚㡿ᇦ↷ᑕ>35Gy࡞ࡾࠊ카㧗ࣜ ࢫࢡ㧗ࣜ ࢫࢡࢆุู࡛ ࡁ࡞࠸ࠋ࣭ MHD5㹼15Gyࡣࠊᚰ⮚㡿ᇦࡢ↷ᑕࡋ࡚ ࠾ࡼࡑ15㹼35Gy ᒙู ࡍࡿ࣭ AYA: Adolescent and Young Adult 15ṓࡽ30ṓ௦ࡢࡀࢇࢧࣂࣂ࣮
㧗ࣜ ࢫࢡ పࣜ ࢫࢡ
࡞ࡋ ᡂே 5ᖺࡈ ᑠඣ࣭ AYA 5ᖺࡈ
ᡂே 5ᖺࡈ ᑠඣ࣭ AYA 2ᖺࡈ
ᡂே 1,3,5ᖺᚋ ࡑࡢᚋࡣ5ᖺࡈ
ᑠඣ࣭ AYA 2ᖺࡈ
p.33
表1
がん治療心血管毒性を引き起こすがん治療
・アントラサイクリン系薬剤・抗HER2 抗体療法・フルオロピリミジン・VEGF 阻害剤(血管新生阻害剤)・BCR/ABL チロシンキナーゼ阻害剤・BTK 阻害剤(ブルトン型チロシンキナーゼ阻害剤)・多発性骨髄腫治療・BRAF/MEK 阻害剤・ICI(免疫チェックポイント阻害剤)・前立腺がんに対するアンドロゲン除去療法・乳がんに対する内分泌療法・CDK4/6 阻害剤・ALK 阻害剤・EGFR 阻害剤・CAR-T 療法・放射線治療・造血幹細胞移植・そのほか
p.34
ڮ &75&' भඪ২ীథ தඪ ਘੱ දؚ ଓஃ୭१এشॺ॑ ਏघॊؚ ऽञमੱ ॑ અൟघॊੱਂ ৸ ඪੱਂ ৸ো॑ ਏघॊৃ় রಉඪ ਗਟदਹႌදधੱਂ ৸ఇभਘ৲॑ ਏघॊৃ় ೄඪ ೄ২भੱਂ ৸ඪ૾ ऋँ ॊऋਘ৲मਂ ਏ ඪ ৗञप/9()धऩढञৃ় ⋇ ⋈भःङोऊ ⋇/9() ऋৗञप٫ਰৣ खधऩढञৃ় ⋈/9() ऋ٫भৣ द/9()٫धऩॉؚ ऊणਰৣ भःङोऊभৃ় */6 भঋش५ছॖ থऊै भৗञऩৼৌऩৣ ق̆ */6كऋ॑ தइॊ ৗञऩੱ ටংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شभಊ
/9()ۺ٫ */6! ऊणऽञम ৗञऩੱ ටংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شभಊ
ੱ ටংॖ ड़ঐشढ़شभಊ؟F7Q,F7Q7 भ٫ॱॖ ঝਰभಊؚ %13ۺSJPO17SUR%13ۺSJPO ऽञमঋش५ছॖ থऊै भৗञऩથਔऩಊقઞ৷॔ ॵ७ॖ भে৾ ؚੰ ෲऩෙ୷॑ தइॊु भك
p.35
ऋ॒ ఇ১पਏऩੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभ৯ ಹقറୁ ك ૹષ တੱ ग़॥شॱॖ থॢ ॻय़९ঝঅ३থ॔ ॻজ॔ ३থ জ५ॡ؟ १ॖ ॡঝ৯ ফ রজ५ॡ؟ १ॖ ॡঝ৯ ফ ৈজ५ॡ؟؞؞ڲ१ॖ ॡঝ৯ ऊা ফ রজ५ॡदमॻय़९ঝঅ३থఌद ⋸P தइञৎ ਡदु တ
আছঝঅ३থ ॸছঝঅ३থ ই॓ ঝঔঝঅ३থ ग़আঝঅ३থ
ই॓ ঝঔঝঅ३থ ॻय़९ঝঅ३থවজ९شଲද ॻय़३ঝಿ ॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈঁ ش७উॳথ রজ५ॡ؟ র ऊা ৈজ५ॡ؟ র ऊা
ॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈ ग़ॱথ३থ ढ़ॻ१ॖ ছ ॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈ ॹঝ५ॸढ़থ ग़থঁ شॶ ঌঝॶ६ঐঈ ঃش४ख़ॱ ঌঝॶ६ঐঈ؞ॺছ५ॶ६ঐঈଦ় ইख़५० ঋং३ॶ६ঐঈ॔ ং५ॳথ জ५ॡ؟ রজ५ॡ؟ র ऊা ৈজ५ॡ؟ র ऊা தৈজ५ॡदम੶पਸइؚ ౝ৯॔
ইজঋঝ७উॺ २ঝॺছॵউ ছ३ঝঐঈ १ॖ ছ२ ५ॽॳॽঈ ५شॸথॺ ९ছইख़ॽঈ ॿॡ१ংشঝ ঃ॰ঃॽঈ দज़ॺজग़থॺ
p.36
॔य़३ॳॽঈॖ থছॖ ॱ ঞ०ছইख़ॽঈ ५ॳংشफ़ ংথॹॱॽঈ ढ़উঞঝ१ এॼॳॽঈ॔ॖ ॡঝ३ॢ ढ़१থॳॽঈ ढ़ওॸॕ ॡ५ ঞথংॳॽঈ ঞথঅঐ অজঐঈ খشॖ
ॽঝঐঈ ड़উ४ش हউটজ६ঐঈ य़ॖ ॺঝشॲ॔ ঋঝঐঈ ংঋথॳड़॔ ॸ॰জ६ঐঈ ॸ७থॺজॡ ॹॕ ঝংঝঐঈॖ ইॕ থ४ ॺঞওজঐঈॖ ४গॻ ७উজঐঈ জঈॱচ
p.37
৫भ*/6 पे ॊॖ ঋথॺ قফك ॹ२ॖ থ ৌ
قඪਯك ढ़ॵॺड़ইக ୯ ಖ২؞ટ
ौऌ ॥شॺ
৸ऋ॒ ர ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ
ਫ਼ୈऩख قக؟ ك
রఙக ফ
*/6 म0$&(ؚ ৸ଈಝभஆয়
ौऌ ॥شॺ
৸ऋ॒ ர ق ك
৲৾ ১ق ك
ਫ਼ୈऩख قக؟ ك
ਈশ ফ */6 म৸ଈಝभஆয়
ौऌ ॥شॺ
ഷั பਙᇯᯂ ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ
ॡজথ রఙக
ফ
*/6मੱਂ ৸ੱ ഷଵ ଈଈಝभজ५ॡऋ धऩ ॉؚ */6 मஆয়
ऌ ॥شॺ
பਙজথঃᇯ ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ
ॡজথ ऊা
*/6 भाऋदஆয় दँ ॉؚ */6 助द৲৾ ১भంฌল૨भৣ॑ ૭ચ
ौऌ ॥شॺ
ਙஜഷ୰ ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ
ॡজথ রఙக
ऊা
*/6मਈु ਘৡऩ
ौऌ ॥شॺ
৸ऋ॒ ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ
ॡজথ 努 ऊা */6द&75&' भে
জ५ॡऋಊ
p.38
7KDYHQGLUDQDWKDQHWDO -$P&ROO&DUGLRO
ऌ 5&7
ৈজ५ॡ೩ पऋ॒ ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ ॺছ५ॶ६ ঐঈ
ਫ਼ୈऩख ফ */6 फ़ॖ ॻৣ पे ॊੱ ৳૧ఇ
োमంฌল૨भৣ॑ ଆ
ऌ ॥شॺ
ऋ॒ ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথٔ VHTXHQWLDO WDUJHWHG WKHUDS\
ऊা ফ ऊাৎਡभ*/6 ऋ
ਙ&75&'॑
ऌ 5&7
+(5഻ ਙऋ॒ ك
శ॔ থॺছ१ॖ
ॡজথ ਫ਼ୈऩख ফ
জ५ॡ؞శ॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজ থઞ৷ණदमؚ */6 भৣ ऋँ ढथु ଆఇऋਂ ਏदँ ॊ૭ ચਙ॑ંྮ
ौऌ ॥شॺ
பਙজথঃᇯ ق ك॔
থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ ଣೝ১
ਫ਼ୈऩख রఙக
ফ
ంฌল૨ऋਫଞदु */6 ऋ ཿਙੱ ਙभपથ৷
p.39
,&,ۢ ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भ൧੦ ୰৶৾ ન൧ੱ ൙ཝभै ऊऩശଈ॑ൣ अ༰ਙभ༇ඪਙཝဋق৾ ႀྰ ك ಏ෫൧ ਙ་ඪණृ ഉਙੱ ൙༇॑ ਗखञअइदؚੱ ൙ॺটএॽথகಊٔ ਰৣ भअठ
ਏ੦ ඨ৯ऽञम ઃ੦ ඨ৯ਰ ञघऒध ਏ੦ ਙੱ ൙༇भ&05 ਚৄ قఊਫ/DNH/RXLVH ੦पುكౢ ⋇ ಏ෫ඪقௌؚ ൙൱ؚ ൱ؚ ളଳؚ ళลؚ କౠళลؚৣ ࿔ᇯؚ ᠶؚ ीऽःؚ ଷઋؚ ൙ৡৣؚ ३ঙॵॡك ⋈ ੱ ਙਂ ତဿऽञम૩ ⋉ ంઽೠચৣ قଂਚઈ౮ଞஅिؚ శञऒणऻك ⋊ भLU$(ق൙༇ؚ ൙ඪؚ ඪ൙૮ৡඪك ⋋ ઑॎखः&05 ਚৄ
p.40
,&,ۢ ঢ়৴ੱ ൙༇भඪ২ীథ แඪ ୭ଙਂ ؚ శ؞ଓஃऋਏؚ ৈ২ඬঈটॵॡؚ Ⴟऩਂ ତဿ శแඪ ඪਙटऋ୭ଙؚ ਗ਼ਞ౮ଞ॑ൣ अ೩؛ඊႵঢ়৴ॖ ঋথॺधৎप၉प൧औोॊऒधुँ ॊ؛
ంฌল૨ৣँ ढथु ඪඉऩख؛ ५ॸটॖ ॻಿ ਙ ५ॸটॖ ॻपु ऊऊॎै ङؚੱ ൙༇ऋశབੰँ ॊःमப৲घॊৃ় قभ୰॑ ਗु ॺটএॽথৈகऋ
p.41
ఇ؞ාਙ3+ ඪपঢ়ଖघॊఇ 3$+ ඪषभનৰऩঢ়৴ऋँ ॊु भ 3$+ ඪषभঢ়৴भ૭ચਙऋँ ॊु भ ॲ१ॳॽঈ ঐॖ ॺঐॖ ३থ& ढ़ঝইॕ ঝ॰ঈ॔
ঝय़ঝ৲ද ५ॳॽঈ এॼॳॽঈ ঋং३६ঐঈ ঝॸ॰ঈ
p.42
5,+' ඪभ૫
؞એऽञमంषभසೝ ؞ৈःྸ ଣೝقٜ *\ ؞ফقٛ ୃ ك ؞ ँ ञॉभৈःଣೝقٜ *\GD\ ؞ੱ ටऽञमੱ ටपਤனखञᇯᯂभோ ؞ଣೝᄭ⎱भಳ ؞৲৾ ১भಡ৷ق॔ থॺছ१ॖ ॡজথ௺ఇදभઞ৷ك ؞་૫قႇႌ୰ؚླཱྀ ؚ ෝؚ ৈഷಓؚ ସ౮ଞඪك ؞ੱ ഷଵႈ೩भใ༼
p.43
1 ੱ
ग़॥شपउऐॊਃஓధलपಖ২ଵ৶पঢ়घॊတ ؞ੱ ग़॥شउे लਃஓଵ৶पणःथमؚ फ़ॖ ॻছॖ থपปढञ৳ஹਡਫ਼॑ ষअऒध॑ တघॊ؛ ؞ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪষഄऋँ ॊඪपउःथमؚ ਫ਼ਪपउे लঋش५ছॖ থभੑ கऩै लप൸भ ؞ੱ ग़॥شੑ கपणःथमؚે ীऩ৽ୡ॑ ॒ टਫ਼ऋଳಁ ऩ௬धಱखथःॊऊનੳ॑ ষअ؛ ؞पੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪदੱ ग़॥شੑ கपणःथਫ਼ऩै लपਫ਼ෙ୷पणःथનੳखؚੑ ಖ ২ଵ৶पीॊऒधऋऽखः؛ ؞ੱ ग़॥شਫ਼ਪभಯૃ ऩै लपम൸१شংشप৳ோखؚి ൸ၡ༮ऩै लपગੑ ॑ ষइॊे